Chu Yu looked at the comparison picture, but his eyes were fixed, and he didn't react much. After all, he had long expected that it was Mu Shangqing, and when he saw the five knives, he also sketched the appearance of the murderer in his mind.
Since she took the three remaining officers and dug up Mu Shangqing's corpse in Hua Xie Ting, Xu Huaiyu looked at her with admiration. Although she didn't show it, she already regarded her as a case-solving consultant in her heart. , is better than spending a whole day out to investigate.
In the director's office, Xu Huaiyu was sitting behind the desk, Chu Yu sat opposite him, and Muyu, Fang Datuo, Song Qingyang, and on the sofa next to him, all the key figures in the investigation of this case were there. Xu Huaiyu also provided There was a whiteboard for them to write and draw.
Today, Chu Yu was wearing a lamb wool and fleece padded coat, pure black, with a circle of white fleece on the hat, which made her chin clear and her complexion more calm.
Seeing that she hadn't spoken for a long time, Xu Huaiyu tilted her head and wanted to remind her again, but before she could say anything, Chu Yu suddenly stood up, walked to the whiteboard, picked up the ink pen, spread her shoulders, and took it out to be crazy. The posture of the 800-character composition of the book.
However, with the strength of 800 words, she only wrote down the word "mour".
"Let's start with November 1, five years ago. That night, Chief Mu Ke disappeared mysteriously. The Superman Department and the police found the deceased's mobile phone, shoes and other items on the top floor of the migrant worker's building, as well as a lot of blood. The inspections all came from Chief Mu, and that night, a witness said that when the incident happened, he had seen Chief Mu, who seemed to be fighting with the other side and was at a disadvantage.
At that time, a lot of manpower and material resources were spent to find him, but there was no result. Now, he appears in the flower bed of Hua Xie Ting, we can call it the first scene. "
Xu Huaiyu interrupted her: "Wait, why is this the first scene? What if the murderer killed someone elsewhere and then moved to Hua Xie Court?"
Chu Yu nodded to Song Qingyang, who took out the transcripts made in Fushan Hospital, turned to the corresponding pages, and handed them to Xu Huaiyu.
Xu Huaiyu took a look, and then looked at the dossier that Chu Yu brought yesterday, with a sour tone: "Didn't you say that you have sent all the dossiers? How come there are still fish that slip through the net?"
"At that time, I was in a hurry, and the record fell on Changyan. Muyu and the others came back from Changyan today and brought them back together."
Having said that, Xu Huaiyu knew very well that it seemed that Chu Yu was still hiding a hand. If she didn't cooperate with her, she would not use her trump card.
"You continue."
Chu Yu wrote the word "Xue".
"Xiao Huaihua asked Xue Jinping, who was a martial arts actor in disguise, before carving the Huaihua: Five years ago, what did he do in Huaxie Court? From this, we can judge that on the night of November 2, Xue Jinping was in Huaxie Court."
Xu Huaiyu asked again: "How can you be sure that it is November 2nd? Five years ago, the time spanned one year, including 365 days. How could it be accurate to November 2nd? What if it was November 1st?"
Chu Yu signaled to Muyu, and Muyu walked to Xu Huaiyu's side, turned over the ticket purchase records of He Lan, Xue Jinping and Gong Yanhua in the dossier, and showed him to the old man.
Xu Huaiyu saw it, suddenly realized, and almost slapped his forehead, but he wanted to maintain his posture and keep the appearance of being familiar with the dossier, so he still sat upright, his eyes turned around on the departure date "November 2", and his voice sounded. Duan Dei said: "So you think that the three victims of the Sophora japonica project will all gather in Hua Xie Ting after they arrive in the city on November 2?"
"Yes," Chu Yu wrote "He" on the whiteboard, "We were in Luoyu City and asked He Lan's husband, he said that He Lan had traveled to Wangjiang City twice, and once was Six years ago, I watched all the scenic spots in Wangjiang, once five years ago, but that time I went in a hurry, and I came back in a hurry.
"When I asked He Lan, she knew that Xiao Huai was not only spread through the news, but her original words at the time were: She is about 20 years old this year, has a mental tendency, and is from Wangjiang City, Buncheon Province. If He Lan She has never met Xiao Huaihua, and she can know this information, so she should have met with Chief Mu and learned from Chief Mu."
"Let's look at Gong Yanhua again. Five years ago, Gong Yanhua lived in Xiangzi Village, Pei County, Jinling City. This is also where she and Chen Mu have always lived. After Chen Mu died, Gong Yanhua kept guarding his relics and mourned at home. After a long time of desire, she suddenly put away Chen Mu's posthumous photo after November five years ago and moved to Xi'an Village next door. Pick it up at the market to sell it, and talk and laugh with the neighbors.”
Xu Huaiyu held his chin in his hand, the flesh on his chin was squeezed and piled up several layers, looking anxious and confused.
"Then according to what you said, after spending one night in Hua Xie Court on November 2, Gong Yanhua saw it instead and was freed from Chen Mu's tragic death?"
"It looks like this," Chu Yu shifted his perspective to Hu Bin, "Borui'an and Hu Bin are both locals, we can't find out their whereabouts between November 1st and 2nd, but Hu Bin's After the death of his niece Hu Qingke, Hu Bin was in a state of grief for a time, and wanted to resign from the post of dean and never be a psychiatrist.
"But after November five years ago, he suddenly came out of his sadness and returned to Jinshui Hospital to continue his work. According to the nurses in the hospital, he was more serious than before, treated patients more patiently, and paid more attention to patients' health. psychological feeling."
After Chu Yu wrote down the names, he wrote down the changes of the characters, which was clear and intuitive, but because of the amount of information, Xu Huaiyu still felt that he couldn't keep up with Teacher Chu's rhythm. He took out a notebook from the drawer and wrote it down. Down key messages and take care of your slow reaction time.
Hu Bin and Bo Ruian are both from the city, and Xu Huaiyu personally directed the investigation of the cases related to them, so they are familiar with them. After writing down Hu Bin's condition, he raised his head: "Let's talk about Borian next."
Chu Yu turned to look at Fang Datuo, "Datuo, you were in charge of investigating his situation at the time. Report it again. You said I wrote it."
For the first time, Fang Datuo enjoyed the treatment of sitting on the sofa to give a report, but in front of the two leaders, he moved his butt, which was a little uncomfortable.
"According to our investigation and interviews, since the death of his son Bai Mengmeng, Bai Ruian has been very depressed. During the Chinese New Year, he would take his son to visit relatives and friends, go shopping and buy things, but after his son's accident, even if it is a festival, he will He also rarely walks with relatives and friends, and only works at two o'clock every day, at work or at home.
"Five years ago, after November 2nd, neither his wife Liao Feng nor his neighbors and colleagues noticed that he had changed significantly. He neither became brighter nor more depressed. In contrast, Liao Feng's reaction was much bigger than his. Because of her severe burns, she stayed at home for a long time. At first, she almost lost her mind. However, under the careful care of Bo Ruian over the years, she is in good condition. A lot. The last time I saw her, in terms of mental state, she was almost the same as before Bo Mengmeng's accident. "
Seeing that Chu Yu had finished writing the key points, Fang Da closed the account: "So I think that Bo Ruian has not changed, but it has not completely collapsed. It may be because Liao Feng needs him, because Liao Feng is almost collapsed, If Bo Ruian is more decadent, the whole family will collapse, so he has always maintained a state of neither sadness nor joy, being an ordinary office worker and earning money to support his family."
Xu Huaiyu found out what they had in common, and his eyes lit up: "It seems that after November 2, the status of the victims of the Huaihua project has improved to varying degrees. It seems that the meeting was a good one for them. Something, someone enlightened them?"
"Not necessarily," Chu Yu folded his arms and held the pen between his fingertips, "Xue Jinping was also a victim of the Huaihua case, but she turned out to be mentally normal, but at the end of December five years ago, she was admitted to Fushan Hospital, and she was Four years, never again."
"So what happened on November 2nd?"
On the whiteboard, the stars and the moon have formed. Mu Shangqing is surrounded by the center. The names of the other five people form the outer ring. Chu Yu circles the names of the outer ring, and the arrow points to the deceased "Mu".
"According to the current clues and evidence, I infer that on November 2, five years ago, in Hua Xie Ting, these five people jointly killed Chief Mu and buried him beside the locust tree."
The other four were shocked. The reaction of the three officers was bigger than Xu Huaiyu, their pupils trembled, and they didn't blink for half a minute.
Chu Yu didn't tell them the speculation in advance. She is now pushing directly on the spot without any rehearsal.
Muyu was the first to react, this time instead of helping his boss, he questioned: "Chu, although there is no ticket purchase record for Xiao Huaihua, Huang Li and Wang Zitao said that five years ago on November 1st , It was Xiao Huaihua's birthday, she ran back to Wangjiang, and it stands to reason that she went to find Chief Mu, so the number of people at that time, including Chief Mu, should be seven people."
"I thought at first that it was Xiao Huaihua who met with the other five people, but a few days ago, Xiao Huaihua and Xue Jinping met at Fushan Hospital. After Xue Jinping met her, she didn't respond to her. She said: 'I'm afraid my aunt doesn't recognize me yet, but it's not surprising that you have been closed off for a long time, you don't talk to people, you don't read the news, you don't know me, it's normal'.
"If Xiao Huaihua and Xue Jinping met, but Xue Jinping had forgotten her and had no impression of her, then Xiao Huaihua would have said: 'Why doesn't my aunt know me?' '.
"So, five years ago in Wangjiang City, the five victims of the Huaihua case did not meet with Xiao Huaihua, they only met with Mu Shangqing, killed Mu Shangqing and buried him, while Xiao Huaihua, just witnessed the crime scene!"
Fang Datuo was thoughtful and followed Chu Yu's train of thought: "You just said that Xiao Huaihua asked Xue Jinping: What did you do in Huaxie Ting five years ago? She probably didn't see the murder process. It was the burial, and I saw the locust tree."
Xu Huaiyu stretched out his hand and signaled them to stop, but he couldn't keep up, "However, how can we be sure that these five people are the murderers? We only dug out the bones of Chief Mu and five knives, but we can't just because there are five With a knife, you think the murderers must be five people, right?"
Chu Yu began to write on the blackboard again. Fortunately, her handwriting was clear and not sloppy at all, otherwise the intricate details and lines would have to be mixed into a ghost painting.
"First, like the information we just got, five years ago, it was known that three people came to Wangjiang, and three people had obvious changes, so we speculated that they had a meeting in Huaxie Court, then they did things should also be collective activities;
"Secondly, in Luoyu City, I once asked He Lan why she knew the information about Xiao Huaihua. She didn't tell me the truth, but told me a story. This story is very long, and the main content is as follows: She is watching When Jiang was traveling, he lost his way in the forest park and rushed over to a black dog. She killed the black dog with a knife. Later, she met a little girl who took her out of the forest, but the former girl was right. She said that the black dog is her closest person. When she grows up, she will kill her like she kills dogs.
"Although this is a fabricated story, it has a strong innuendo, because at that time I asked He Lan to ask a question, and suddenly, she didn't have time to make up the story, but she didn't want to tell the truth, so she temporarily processed the truth, the elements in the story. , then point to the truth - the black dog refers to Mu Shangqing, the little girl refers to Xiao Huaihua, the mountain park is Hua Xie Ting, and the knife she used to kill the black dog was the weapon that stabbed Mu Shangqing to death!"
After speaking, Chu Yu lowered her eyes, her voice was beginning to fluctuate. When stating the case, she should be objective and fair, try not to be emotional, so that the audience can judge for themselves and pay attention to the evidence inference itself, rather than the tone and attitude of the speaker. influences.
But Chu Yu's mood fluctuated too much, and her tone couldn't help revealing clues. Although she had a rough guess about the truth before, she only had a vague shadow in her heart. Now, word by word, she said it clearly, vague shadow It became clear that she could even imagine the tragic scene of five people holding knives and besieging Mu Shangqing.
Just imagining it was already unbearable, not to mention that Xia Yihan had witnessed this scene with his own eyes.
In the past, Hu Bin and the others were victims, and Chu Yu always favored them. They had experienced too much suffering. First, their relatives died, and then they were injured. It was not easy to be able to live strong in this world.
So she wanted to capture the Phantom of Sophora japonica and find out the truth, so as to give justice to the five victims. Although they did not cooperate and misled her to handle the case many times, it did not hinder her. She had pity and respect for them.
Now, the truth is slowly coming out, but her position has been shaken. It turned out that the victim was the murderer, and the murderer was the victim who was cornered.
The other four heard the change in Chu Yu's mood, and fell silent one after another. They could empathize with her. After learning about Xiao Huaihua's crime motive, they were shocked and sighed. They didn't know how to judge for a while.
Muyu sighed deeply and asked softly, "Chu, is there a third point?"
"Yes," Chu Yu adjusted his state, and his words were sonorous and powerful. Although his wrists were slender, the words that fell on the whiteboard were sharp and firm.
"Thirdly, it stands to reason that the five of them were stabbed with knives and carved with locust flowers. They should hate the murderer and actively provide information to the police, but they didn't. What's more, they deliberately misled me and gave me false information.
"By doing this, they can confirm my previous inference, because they killed Mu Shangqing, and Xiao Huaihua found them because of the murder case. They didn't provide Xiao Huaihua's information, or even covered her up, just didn't want to. She was caught. Because if Xiao Huaihua is caught, they may tell their crimes and they will go to jail!"
With a sound of "Bang-", Xu Huaiyu threw the notebook on the table, his face turning blue with anger, "I just said, why is it so difficult to handle the case at that time, it's really evil, and the insiders are not cooperating one by one, so it turns out that None of them are good! They should be caught!"
Chu Yu stood on the spot, didn't speak, and clasped his fingers on the edge of the whiteboard, trembling slightly because he was too hard.
Muyu recalled the various details of the previous case, and pondered with horror, "I remember that the police asked Bo Ruian at that time, he said that the murderer was a man, and he was wearing a hat, so he couldn't see his face, but Liao Feng also said later that he took her The person who was dazed was a man. We thought that the murderer was really a man, and even suspected that it was the hand of Chief Mu Ke.
"Now it seems that it is probably like this: After Xiao Huaihua entered the door, she explained her intention to Bai Ruian, and forced him with a gun to tell the truth of the murder case, but Bai Ruian was afraid of disturbing Liao Feng and did not want Liao to let him. Feng knew, so he walked into the kitchen and dazed her, and then he confronted Xiao Huaihua, who probably asked him the same question: What did you do in Hua Xie Ting five years ago? I rummaged through his house, probably looking for evidence that he killed Chief Mu."
Fang Datuo nodded: "Yes, and Xue Jinping, as soon as Xiao Huaihua talked to her about the section chief, she went crazy and rushed to make Xiao Huaihua shut up, because she can't forget the scene of the murder case, she always remembers The appearance of Chief Mu's tragic death has hallucinations, and he feels that he has gone back to find her!"
Chu Yu: "Yes, all of what you said can confirm our inference. Remember the crime scene I tried to restore at first? I guess that the day Xiao Huaihua disappeared from Jinshui Hospital, she stole the nurse's phone and called To Hu Bin, I said that I wanted him to meet her and see her condition. Later, Hu Bin took Xiao Huaihua to the diagnosis room. Xiao Huaihua put on medical gloves, attacked him, and pretended to be a medical staff. Take the scalpel and complete the carving of the Sophora japonica.
"But now it seems that my inference at the time was wrong. Xiao Huaihua should have revealed her identity on the phone. She was Mu Shangqing's daughter and wanted to talk to him about the murder, so Hu Bin brought Xiao Huaihua to the phone. Meeting her alone in a diagnosis room with no one, Xiao Huaihua should have asked him the same question.
"Afterwards, Xiao Huaihua put him down, carved a locust flower, and escaped from Jinshui Hospital, which explains why Hu Bin and Xiao Huaihua met alone without any medical staff."
All four nodded, Xu Huaiyu's complexion turned from blue to purple, and the breath in his chest was still suffocating, he already believed Chu Yu's inference, "Unfortunately, these five people are all injured now, lying on the bed, otherwise I will We have to invite them to sit in the interrogation room, now we have evidence, Chief Mu's body and five murder weapons..."
As he said that, his throat seemed to be stuck, and he turned his head, "No, five people committed the murder, why are there only four bloodstains on the four knives?"
Chu Yu pursed her lips and stood beside the white board. The cotton-padded clothes on her body became darker and darker, and her expression became calmer, pressing down the turbulent undercurrents under her skin.
"This involves the question of the motive for committing the crime, which is why they killed Section Chief Mu."
She turned around and faced the intricate clues. Five murderers surrounded the deceased. The name of each murderer spread out again, listing their own experiences, changes before and after, concealed information from the police, and what was missing now. , that is, their respective motives, or their common motives.
"The question of motivation, which I haven't figured out yet, is something we need to investigate later."
As she said that, she held the ink pen lightly with her index finger, and touched a small black dot on the outer ring, ready to write down a person's name, but in the end she didn't write anything and put the pen down.