The two lawyers stood in the middle of the courtroom, both facing sideways in the direction of the gallery.
Gu Nianzhi simply walked down holding the cartoon picture, walked around the auditorium, and showed it to everyone up close before walking back to the middle of the courtroom.
Lu Anpeng was a little disdainful of Gu Nianzhi's sensational behavior, but he didn't show it.
After Gu Nianzhi stood still, Lu Anpeng said: "Barrister Gu, are you sure that the murder of Barrister Qin Suwen started when she was eight years old and ended on the day of her death?"
Gu Nianzhi nodded, "That's right."
Lu Anpeng chuckled, "That's good. This proves that my client, Ms. Qin Yaoguang, was not the murderer of Barrister Qin Suwen at all."
He turned to face the judge and said loudly: "When Qin Suwen was eight years old, Ms. Qin Yaoguang was only nine years old. If the murder really started at that time, then it has nothing to do with my client, Ms. Qin Yaoguang. I I once again request the court to declare this case invalid and not to continue pursuing my client’s responsibility and trouble.”
Gu Nianzhi raised his hand and tapped Lu Anpeng's shoulder again, and said bluntly: "Lawyer Lu, who said that a nine-year-old can't participate in murder? Isn't it too preconceived of you to say that?"
Lu Anpeng looked back at her and really felt that Gu Nianzhi was messing around. He frowned and said, "Even if a nine-year-old can participate in murder, according to our country's criminal law, minors under the age of fourteen do not have to commit any crime. bear any criminal responsibility. So, your honor, can this case be dropped?"
Gu Nianzhi smiled and said, "Lawyer Lu has always wanted to cancel this case. Unfortunately, the facts are not satisfactory."
Before the judge made a judgment, Gu Nianzhi had already said quickly: "Your honor, people under the age of fourteen do not have to bear criminal responsibility for crimes, but what about adults?"
She took a step forward and almost asked Lu Anpeng's face: "Lawyer Lu, don't forget, I just said that this murder took more than thirty years. Qin Yaoguang has long been an adult. You said she can't bear it." Legal liability?!—Who makes the law? You?"
Lu Anpeng frowned and took a step back, and said displeasedly: "Barrister Gu, you mean that my client started planning the murder when she was nine years old, and it was not until more than thirty years later that she committed the murder. Success? Don’t you think this is ridiculous?”
Gu Nianzhi shook his head and said with a smile, "I don't think so."
He also praised Lu Anpeng: "As expected of a barrister, he saw the truth of this case at a glance!"
Lu Anpeng chuckled, "Barrister Gu, I didn't mean that. From beginning to end, I didn't think my client had anything to do with the death of Barrister Qin Suwen!"
"Is it true?" Gu Nianzhi waved the dark comic picture that he just snatched from Lu Anpeng's hand in front of him, "But look, how do you explain this?"
Lu Anpeng took another step back, pursed his lips and stopped talking.
Gu Nianzhi turned to face the people in the auditorium and the cameras on the wall, and said calmly: "I just proved that Qin Yaoguang had the motive to murder Barrister Qin Suwen. Now let's talk about Qin Yaoguang's method of murdering Barrister Qin Suwen. That is, how she killed Barrister Qin Suwen."
After a pause, Gu Nianzhi walked back to his plaintiff's seat, opened his laptop, connected it directly to the court's projector, and projected a forensic report and a doctor's diagnosis report onto the white projection screen.
Court technicians immediately dimmed the lights in the courtroom a little, but not completely as before.
Everyone's attention was attracted by the two reports on the white projection screen.
Gu Nianzhi pointed to the forensic report and said, "This shows that Barrister Qin Suwen died suddenly because of a heart problem."
"The doctor's diagnosis report next to her was made when Barrister Qin Suwen was young, proving that she had congenital heart disease."
"According to the information I found, congenital heart disease is related to heredity and is determined by genes."
"People with congenital heart disease will run in their families."
As Gu Nianzhi said, he clicked the mouse again and replaced two other physical examination reports and doctor's certificates.
"I also have two pieces of evidence here, provided by Qin Zhiyuan and Qin Zhining, two nephews of Barrister Qin Suwen."
Gu Nianzhi glanced in the direction where Qin Zhiyuan and Qin Zhining were sitting, and nodded to them.
Lu Anpeng also took a look and recognized Qin Zhiyuan and Qin Zhining.
He served as Qin Yaoguang's defense lawyer and had a very clear and thorough understanding of the people and things related to Qin Suwen. Of course, he also investigated Qin Suwen's family relationships.
"Please see, the two diagnoses just made prove that Qin Zhiyuan and Qin Zhining do not have congenital heart disease, and their DNA test also proves that they do not have the gene for this, so I would like to ask Barrister Qin Su Where does congenital heart disease come from?"
Gu Nianzhi put one hand behind his back, walked up to Qin Yaoguang, looked at her with a smile, and said, "Ms. Qin Yaoguang, as a scientist in biogenetic medicine, can you explain to us why Qin Zhiyuan and Qin Zhining People don’t have genes for congenital heart disease?”
Perhaps because Lu Anpeng always had the upper hand, Qin Yaoguang was not impatient and maintained her demeanor. She did not answer Gu Nianzhi's question immediately, but looked at her defense lawyer Lu Anpeng.
Lu Anpeng walked over, stretched out his hand, tapped the defendant's seat twice, and said to Gu Nianzhi: "Lawyer Gu, my client does not need to answer this question. I have already invited an expert witness. He is the best person in the world." A well-known cardiac surgeon with absolute authority in congenital heart disease can answer your questions.”
"Oh?" Gu Nianzhi deliberately looked like he was sure of victory, tilted his head and said proudly: "Then can your expert witness explain it to you?"
Lu Anpeng immediately applied to the court for the expert witness to appear in court.
His witness list has been submitted to the court long ago, and all the necessary procedures have been completed.
Therefore, the judge quickly agreed to his application and had the expert witness waiting in the next room brought in.
The expert witness who followed the bailiff in was a middle-aged man about the same age as Lu Anpeng. He was very tall and looked very strong and fit. At first glance, he looked like the kind of person who regularly exercises.
Wearing a light gray thin woolen suit and a silver-grey striped tie, he stood on the witness stand, read the witness oath with the bailiff, and then sat down.
After the judge verified his identity, he said: "Dr. Cen, the prosecution lawyer has a question about congenital heart disease. I hope you can answer it from an academic perspective."
Dr. Cen nodded, "Your honor, I will do my best to answer the prosecution lawyer's questions."
Gu Nianzhi smiled and nodded to him, and asked the question again.
Lu Anpeng also introduced the background of the issue: "The prosecution lawyer just said that congenital heart disease is determined by genes, that is, heredity."
"So she started with Barrister Qin Suwen's family to prove that there was no genetic gene for congenital heart disease in her family. This proved that Barrister Qin Suwen did not have congenital heart disease. Then the cause of her death is worthy of discussion."
Gu Nianzhi nodded and almost applauded him, "Lawyer Lu summed it up well! That's what I meant!"
Lu Anpeng: "..."
Something seemed wrong, but he asked himself that his logic and common sense were impeccable.
At this time, Dr. Cen seriously took out a piece of information from his briefcase and retorted: "The premise of what the prosecution lawyer just said about congenital heart disease is wrong."
"This is an authoritative article on congenital heart disease in medicine. It proves that there are many causes of congenital heart disease, and genes, that is, genetic factors, actually only account for 8% of the incidence of congenital heart disease."
"Ninety-two percent of congenital heart disease is caused by environmental factors. Especially when women are affected to a certain extent during pregnancy, especially during the critical period of fetal heart development, it will also cause fetal diseases. on congenital heart disease.”
Gu Nianzhi looked surprised at this time and interrupted: "Isn't it right? External influences can also cause congenital heart disease in the fetus?! Dr. Cen, what are the external influences? Can you tell us?"
Dr. Cen said professionally: "The early heart development period of the fetus is very critical. If the mother takes inappropriate drugs at this time, is infected with a virus, or is exposed to environmental pollution, radiation, etc., it will seriously affect the fetal development. The development of the heart greatly increases the possibility of the fetus suffering from congenital heart disease."
Gu Nianzhi exclaimed with great professionalism: "Virus?! Can viral infection also cause congenital heart disease in the fetus?! - This completely overturns my understanding of congenital heart disease? I thought it was genetic , which is caused by genetics..."
Dr. Cen smiled gently and said: "No, your understanding is wrong. Most congenital heart disease has nothing to do with genetics. The impact of viruses is indeed relatively large. If the mother is infected with rubella virus in the first 3 months of pregnancy, the fetus will have Ninety percent chance of having congenital heart disease.”
Lu Anpeng interrupted at this time and said: "Our expert witnesses have confirmed that most congenital heart disease has nothing to do with heredity, so even if Attorney Gu proves that brothers Qin Zhiyuan and Qin Zhining do not have the genetic gene for congenital heart disease, it cannot It proves that Barrister Qin Suwen does not have congenital heart disease."
"In this way, Barrister Qin Suwen suffered a sudden congenital heart disease, which led to her sudden death. It has nothing to do with my client, Ms. Qin Yaoguang."
Gu Nianzhi glanced at him with a smile and did not answer his question, but continued to question the expert witness.
"Then you mean that after the mother is infected by the virus, she passes the placenta, placenta and blood and then transmits the virus to the fetus, thus causing the fetus to become sick, right?"
Dr. Cen nodded, "That's right, the fetus must be infected with the virus to become sick."
Gu Nianzhi immediately asked: "That means that what makes a person sick is the virus, and it has nothing to do with its transmission channel."
"As long as the human body is infected by a virus, whether it is acquired from the mother or acquired after birth, it will cause disease, right?"
Dr. Cen hesitated for a moment, then nodded, "Theoretically, that's the case."
Gu Nianzhi immediately asked: "So if someone injects the virus directly into a person, will that person also have the same symptoms of congenital heart disease?"
Lu Anpeng's face suddenly darkened.
He finally understood where Gu Nianzhi was going to start!
※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※
This is the first update today: Chapter 1880 "Cause of Death".
Remind everyone of monthly tickets and recommended tickets~~~
Today is Monday, especially recommendation votes are very important~~~
There will be a second update at 8pm.
Hey guys, little angels~~~
╰(*°▽°*)╯