Far across the Atlantic in Germany, in a crystal chemistry class at the University of Munich.
Professor Gerhard Ettel rarely left the teaching tasks to his teaching assistants, but stood in the classroom himself to explain the mysteries of crystal chemistry to these young students.
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
Professor Gerhard Ettel rarely left the teaching tasks to his teaching assistants, but stood in the classroom himself to explain the mysteries of crystal chemistry to these young students.
"We can send an invitation letter to Princeton, inviting Professor Lu to visit the Max Planck Institute for exchanges, and provide him with a platform to express his views to the entire theoretical chemistry community."
As a member of the research team and director of the Institute of Physical Chemistry, Ettel's opinions also represent the opinions of the Max Planck Institute of Physical Chemistry.
Indifference to application is the consistent position of the Bourbaki school, and "glorious isolation" from other disciplines is usually regarded as noble. Although it is difficult to feel this chain of contempt within the discipline among younger mathematicians, this stubborn concept still exists among the older generation of mathematicians.
Because the voices were so consistent, both Faltins and Ertel were stunned for a moment after finishing speaking.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
The Max Planck Society is not a top-down centralized research institution, and the various institutes are basically independent of each other.
For a Nobel Prize-level scholar, this kind of teaching and educating people seems a bit humiliating. However, in fact, many well-known scholars enjoy it and are willing to share their knowledge with young students.
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
"We can send an invitation letter to Princeton, inviting Professor Lu to visit the Max Planck Institute for exchanges, and provide him with a platform to express his views to the entire theoretical chemistry community."
Professor Ertel paused for about two seconds, pushed up his reading glasses, and nodded.
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
Ertel exchanged glances with Klitzing and decided not to exchange a word with the stubborn old man until he had read the last part of the paper.
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
"That's enough, Mr. Faltings, we hope you will provide more constructive suggestions instead of listening to you ridicule us."
"We can send an invitation letter to Princeton, inviting Professor Lu to visit the Max Planck Institute for exchanges, and provide him with a platform to express his views to the entire theoretical chemistry community."
Frowning slightly, Faltings said in an emphatic tone: "He is a mathematician."
At this point, Eitel tapped the desk with the lesson plan.
Engaging in basic education can always inspire him at critical moments.
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
"Since you can't make up your mind, why not just come to our Institute of Condensed Matter Physics..."
Far across the Atlantic in Germany, in a crystal chemistry class at the University of Munich.
The two said almost in unison.
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
The two said almost in unison.
During the question-and-answer session at the end of the class, a student suddenly raised his hand and asked.
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
Professor Ertel paused for about two seconds, pushed up his reading glasses, and nodded.
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
In the field of electrochemistry, who else has more say than him
"Professor, have you read the paper on the theoretical model of electrochemical structure interface that was recently published in JACS?"
"I will have the teaching assistant send the homework to your email. Now, get out of class is over."
Unfortunately, Hardy never dreamed that his research results would eventually be taken away by "cunning" application scientists, and would be widely used in computers and cryptography...
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
Klitsin nodded in agreement.
"Have seen it, are there any questions?"
It is precisely for this reason that he is particularly cautious when dealing with this topic.
Professor Ertel paused for about two seconds, pushed up his reading glasses, and nodded.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
Klitsin nodded in agreement.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
Eitel and Kriching breathed a sigh of relief.
"Have seen it, are there any questions?"
Of course, this kind of statement is not just about casually expressing opinions and taking sides.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
As a member of the research team and director of the Institute of Physical Chemistry, Ettel's opinions also represent the opinions of the Max Planck Institute of Physical Chemistry.
I have to say, this is a good idea.
Professor Ertel paused for about two seconds, pushed up his reading glasses, and nodded.
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
physicist tradition.
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
"Since you can't make up your mind, why not just come to our Institute of Condensed Matter Physics..."
If Professor Faltings thinks there is no problem, then basically in a mathematical sense, there should be no problem.
Otherwise, he would not have become the director of the Max Planck Institute of Mathematics.
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
"But while you are curious about new things, I hope you can always remember to examine every conclusion we make with a rigorous attitude."
I have to say, this is a good idea.
During the question-and-answer session at the end of the class, a student suddenly raised his hand and asked.
"We can send an invitation letter to Princeton, inviting Professor Lu to visit the Max Planck Institute for exchanges, and provide him with a platform to express his views to the entire theoretical chemistry community."
However, the student didn't seem to be satisfied with this vague answer. He changed the question and continued to ask the question: "What if it is correct?"
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
At this point, Eitel tapped the desk with the lesson plan.
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
"That's enough, Mr. Faltings, we hope you will provide more constructive suggestions instead of listening to you ridicule us."
At this point, Eitel tapped the desk with the lesson plan.
"There are no ifs in science, but if you have to ask this..."
New chemistry!
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
Seeing that the two were arguing, Kliting coughed slightly and put forward a compromise opinion.
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
"Heads are eliminated, tails continue." He took out a coin from his pocket and slapped it on the table. Professor Klitzing paused and continued slightly excitedly, "Of course, for the sake of fairness, I will also participate."
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
Professor Gerhard Ettel rarely left the teaching tasks to his teaching assistants, but stood in the classroom himself to explain the mysteries of crystal chemistry to these young students.
There was an incredible exclamation in the classroom.
Otherwise, he would not have become the director of the Max Planck Institute of Mathematics.
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
New chemistry!
Sitting down opposite Faltings, Ertel raised his eyebrows: "I don't agree with your point of view."
Frowning slightly, Faltings said in an emphatic tone: "He is a mathematician."
What a shocking statement!
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
"I don't expect you to agree. Just like not everyone can appreciate ancient Greek sculptures, you can't expect a layman to understand the beauty of pure mathematics." Faltings said lightly.
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
Sitting down opposite Faltings, Ertel raised his eyebrows: "I don't agree with your point of view."
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
Fortunately, Faltings had no intention of continuing to speak and carefully read the paper in his hand.
The two said almost in unison.
New chemistry!
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
As a member of the research team and director of the Institute of Physical Chemistry, Ettel's opinions also represent the opinions of the Max Planck Institute of Physical Chemistry.
Professor Claus von Klitzing is a member of the Max Planck Institute for Condensed Matter Physics. Although he is not the director, he is the discoverer of the quantum Hall effect and a Nobel laureate.
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
If Professor Faltings thinks there is no problem, then basically in a mathematical sense, there should be no problem.
Professor Gerhard Ettel rarely left the teaching tasks to his teaching assistants, but stood in the classroom himself to explain the mysteries of crystal chemistry to these young students.
"I am very happy to see that you are optimistic about the birth of a new theory. You are right. Only by constantly accepting new things can we make progress."
"Of course it's our Institute of Physical Chemistry."
In the field of electrochemistry, who else has more say than him
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
However, the student didn't seem to be satisfied with this vague answer. He changed the question and continued to ask the question: "What if it is correct?"
Tapping his index finger on the conference table, Klitsin asked thoughtfully: "What do you think is more appropriate?"
"I am very happy to see that you are optimistic about the birth of a new theory. You are right. Only by constantly accepting new things can we make progress."
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
I have to say, this is a good idea.
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
Professor Ertel paused for about two seconds, pushed up his reading glasses, and nodded.
Indifference to application is the consistent position of the Bourbaki school, and "glorious isolation" from other disciplines is usually regarded as noble. Although it is difficult to feel this chain of contempt within the discipline among younger mathematicians, this stubborn concept still exists among the older generation of mathematicians.
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
I have to say, this is a good idea.
During the question-and-answer session at the end of the class, a student suddenly raised his hand and asked.
Eitel and Kriching breathed a sigh of relief.
"I am very happy to see that you are optimistic about the birth of a new theory. You are right. Only by constantly accepting new things can we make progress."
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
In the field of electrochemistry, who else has more say than him
"impossible."
Engaging in basic education can always inspire him at critical moments.
"But while you are curious about new things, I hope you can always remember to examine every conclusion we make with a rigorous attitude."
"From a mathematical perspective, there's nothing wrong with his process."
"There are no ifs in science, but if you have to ask this..."
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
Eitel looked at him with disbelief and argued rationally: "But what we are discussing now is a chemical problem."
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
"It's about being responsible for science."
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
Considering the importance of this theoretical model to the study of electrochemical interface structures, the Max Planck Society established an interdisciplinary research group, which brought together top scholars in the fields of mathematics, chemistry, and condensed matter physics to discuss this theoretical model.
"Of course it's our Institute of Physical Chemistry."
"Only second-rate mathematicians are interested in how to apply mathematics to solve real-world problems. In my opinion, this kind of thing has no value in reading at all."
"I agree with your point of view, but the question is, which institute will issue the invitation?"
"It's about being responsible for science."
At this point, Eitel tapped the desk with the lesson plan.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
"But while you are curious about new things, I hope you can always remember to examine every conclusion we make with a rigorous attitude."
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
"I will have the teaching assistant send the homework to your email. Now, get out of class is over."
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
"I will have the teaching assistant send the homework to your email. Now, get out of class is over."
Eitel looked at him with disbelief and argued rationally: "But what we are discussing now is a chemical problem."
Facing the joint efforts of the two big guys, Klitsin coughed slightly in embarrassment: "I just said casually... In this case, let's make the decision using the traditional and ancient method."
"Of course it's our Institute of Mathematics."
Seeing that the two were arguing, Kliting coughed slightly and put forward a compromise opinion.
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
The two said almost in unison.
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
Fortunately, Faltings had no intention of continuing to speak and carefully read the paper in his hand.
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
There was an incredible exclamation in the classroom.
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
Considering the importance of this theoretical model to the study of electrochemical interface structures, the Max Planck Society established an interdisciplinary research group, which brought together top scholars in the fields of mathematics, chemistry, and condensed matter physics to discuss this theoretical model.
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
"But while you are curious about new things, I hope you can always remember to examine every conclusion we make with a rigorous attitude."
"From a mathematical perspective, there's nothing wrong with his process."
Of course, this kind of statement is not just about casually expressing opinions and taking sides.
"There are no ifs in science, but if you have to ask this..."
This is a very critical question.
The two said almost in unison.
Considering the importance of this theoretical model to the study of electrochemical interface structures, the Max Planck Society established an interdisciplinary research group, which brought together top scholars in the fields of mathematics, chemistry, and condensed matter physics to discuss this theoretical model.
"I don't expect you to agree. Just like not everyone can appreciate ancient Greek sculptures, you can't expect a layman to understand the beauty of pure mathematics." Faltings said lightly.
The Max Planck Society is not a top-down centralized research institution, and the various institutes are basically independent of each other.
This is a very critical question.
Professor Claus von Klitzing is a member of the Max Planck Institute for Condensed Matter Physics. Although he is not the director, he is the discoverer of the quantum Hall effect and a Nobel laureate.
As a member of the research team and director of the Institute of Physical Chemistry, Ettel's opinions also represent the opinions of the Max Planck Institute of Physical Chemistry.
As a member of the research team and director of the Institute of Physical Chemistry, Ettel's opinions also represent the opinions of the Max Planck Institute of Physical Chemistry.
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
It is precisely for this reason that he is particularly cautious when dealing with this topic.
Far across the Atlantic in Germany, in a crystal chemistry class at the University of Munich.
Facing the joint efforts of the two big guys, Klitsin coughed slightly in embarrassment: "I just said casually... In this case, let's make the decision using the traditional and ancient method."
Considering the importance of this theoretical model to the study of electrochemical interface structures, the Max Planck Society established an interdisciplinary research group, which brought together top scholars in the fields of mathematics, chemistry, and condensed matter physics to discuss this theoretical model.
I have to say, this is a good idea.
"I agree with your point of view, but the question is, which institute will issue the invitation?"
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
It is precisely for this reason that he is particularly cautious when dealing with this topic.
Entering the conference room, he saw Faltings already sitting there, holding a printed paper document in his hand, examining it meticulously.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
The Max Planck Society is not a top-down centralized research institution, and the various institutes are basically independent of each other.
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
Faltins said slowly, as if he was telling Etel on purpose.
This is a very critical question.
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
Professor Gerhard Ettel rarely left the teaching tasks to his teaching assistants, but stood in the classroom himself to explain the mysteries of crystal chemistry to these young students.
At the same time, as one of the most influential mathematicians after Grothendieck and director of the Max Planck Institute for Mathematics, it is also necessary to have an understanding of other research directions.
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
Kliting's heart moved slightly: "What do you mean?"
"Professor, have you read the paper on the theoretical model of electrochemical structure interface that was recently published in JACS?"
Eitel and Kriching breathed a sigh of relief.
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
"From a mathematical perspective, there's nothing wrong with his process."
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
Otherwise, he would not have become the director of the Max Planck Institute of Mathematics.
Facing the joint efforts of the two big guys, Klitsin coughed slightly in embarrassment: "I just said casually... In this case, let's make the decision using the traditional and ancient method."
"Of course it's our Institute of Physical Chemistry."
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
However, this arrogant Germanic old man had this temper when he was at Princeton. After returning to his hometown in Germany, not only did he not change at all, but he became even worse.
"Have seen it, are there any questions?"
Eitel and Kriching breathed a sigh of relief.
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
However, this arrogant Germanic old man had this temper when he was at Princeton. After returning to his hometown in Germany, not only did he not change at all, but he became even worse.
Klitsin nodded in agreement.
"That's enough, Mr. Faltings, we hope you will provide more constructive suggestions instead of listening to you ridicule us."
There was an incredible exclamation in the classroom.
Seeing that the two of them were about to quarrel again, Professor Claus von Klitzing coughed slightly and tried to smooth things over with a helpless tone.
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
"Have seen it, are there any questions?"
Faltins said slowly, as if he was telling Etel on purpose.
New chemistry!
What a shocking statement!
Far across the Atlantic in Germany, in a crystal chemistry class at the University of Munich.
"From a mathematical perspective, there's nothing wrong with his process."
If Professor Faltings thinks there is no problem, then basically in a mathematical sense, there should be no problem.
At the same time, as one of the most influential mathematicians after Grothendieck and director of the Max Planck Institute for Mathematics, it is also necessary to have an understanding of other research directions.
"Only second-rate mathematicians are interested in how to apply mathematics to solve real-world problems. In my opinion, this kind of thing has no value in reading at all."
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
Kliting's heart moved slightly: "What do you mean?"
Indifference to application is the consistent position of the Bourbaki school, and "glorious isolation" from other disciplines is usually regarded as noble. Although it is difficult to feel this chain of contempt within the discipline among younger mathematicians, this stubborn concept still exists among the older generation of mathematicians.
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
However, this arrogant Germanic old man had this temper when he was at Princeton. After returning to his hometown in Germany, not only did he not change at all, but he became even worse.
However, this arrogant Germanic old man had this temper when he was at Princeton. After returning to his hometown in Germany, not only did he not change at all, but he became even worse.
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
The outstanding representative among them is probably the late number theory master Hardy. Apart from research, what this talented person loved to do most was to show off to others that he studied the purest and purest mathematics, and there was no mathematics in his research. "purpose" other than that, and be proud of it.
Because the voices were so consistent, both Faltins and Ertel were stunned for a moment after finishing speaking.
"impossible."
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
Unfortunately, Hardy never dreamed that his research results would eventually be taken away by "cunning" application scientists, and would be widely used in computers and cryptography...
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
Ertel exchanged glances with Klitzing and decided not to exchange a word with the stubborn old man until he had read the last part of the paper.
Seeing that the two of them were about to quarrel again, Professor Claus von Klitzing coughed slightly and tried to smooth things over with a helpless tone.
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
"Don't even think about it!"
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
"It's about being responsible for science."
"Don't even think about it!"
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
Eitel and Kriching breathed a sigh of relief.
The outstanding representative among them is probably the late number theory master Hardy. Apart from research, what this talented person loved to do most was to show off to others that he studied the purest and purest mathematics, and there was no mathematics in his research. "purpose" other than that, and be proud of it.
Professor Ertel paused for about two seconds, pushed up his reading glasses, and nodded.
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
The two said almost in unison.
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
For a Nobel Prize-level scholar, this kind of teaching and educating people seems a bit humiliating. However, in fact, many well-known scholars enjoy it and are willing to share their knowledge with young students.
"I don't expect you to agree. Just like not everyone can appreciate ancient Greek sculptures, you can't expect a layman to understand the beauty of pure mathematics." Faltings said lightly.
At the same time, as one of the most influential mathematicians after Grothendieck and director of the Max Planck Institute for Mathematics, it is also necessary to have an understanding of other research directions.
"There are no ifs in science, but if you have to ask this..."
"It's about being responsible for science."
Sitting down opposite Faltings, Ertel raised his eyebrows: "I don't agree with your point of view."
"I don't expect you to agree. Just like not everyone can appreciate ancient Greek sculptures, you can't expect a layman to understand the beauty of pure mathematics." Faltings said lightly.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
"From a mathematical perspective, there's nothing wrong with his process."
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
"Of course it's our Institute of Physical Chemistry."
"I don't expect you to agree. Just like not everyone can appreciate ancient Greek sculptures, you can't expect a layman to understand the beauty of pure mathematics." Faltings said lightly.
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
Considering the importance of this theoretical model to the study of electrochemical interface structures, the Max Planck Society established an interdisciplinary research group, which brought together top scholars in the fields of mathematics, chemistry, and condensed matter physics to discuss this theoretical model.
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
Otherwise, he would not have become the director of the Max Planck Institute of Mathematics.
This is a very critical question.
"I don't expect you to agree. Just like not everyone can appreciate ancient Greek sculptures, you can't expect a layman to understand the beauty of pure mathematics." Faltings said lightly.
Tapping his index finger on the conference table, Klitsin asked thoughtfully: "What do you think is more appropriate?"
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
Seeing that the two of them were about to quarrel again, Professor Claus von Klitzing coughed slightly and tried to smooth things over with a helpless tone.
The two said almost in unison.
"I am very happy to see that you are optimistic about the birth of a new theory. You are right. Only by constantly accepting new things can we make progress."
What a shocking statement!
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
Of course it's a bet.
"It's about being responsible for science."
The outstanding representative among them is probably the late number theory master Hardy. Apart from research, what this talented person loved to do most was to show off to others that he studied the purest and purest mathematics, and there was no mathematics in his research. "purpose" other than that, and be proud of it.
"That's enough, Mr. Faltings, we hope you will provide more constructive suggestions instead of listening to you ridicule us."
"That's enough, Mr. Faltings, we hope you will provide more constructive suggestions instead of listening to you ridicule us."
The Max Planck Society is not a top-down centralized research institution, and the various institutes are basically independent of each other.
Professor Claus von Klitzing is a member of the Max Planck Institute for Condensed Matter Physics. Although he is not the director, he is the discoverer of the quantum Hall effect and a Nobel laureate.
The two said almost in unison.
Entering the conference room, he saw Faltings already sitting there, holding a printed paper document in his hand, examining it meticulously.
Of course it's a bet.
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
"It's about being responsible for science."
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
If Professor Faltings thinks there is no problem, then basically in a mathematical sense, there should be no problem.
What a shocking statement!
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
At the same time, as one of the most influential mathematicians after Grothendieck and director of the Max Planck Institute for Mathematics, it is also necessary to have an understanding of other research directions.
Ertel exchanged glances with Klitzing and decided not to exchange a word with the stubborn old man until he had read the last part of the paper.
I have to say, this is a good idea.
"We can send an invitation letter to Princeton, inviting Professor Lu to visit the Max Planck Institute for exchanges, and provide him with a platform to express his views to the entire theoretical chemistry community."
Klitsin nodded in agreement.
Ertel exchanged glances with Klitzing and decided not to exchange a word with the stubborn old man until he had read the last part of the paper.
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
Fortunately, Faltings had no intention of continuing to speak and carefully read the paper in his hand.
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
Otherwise, he would not have become the director of the Max Planck Institute of Mathematics.
Facing the joint efforts of the two big guys, Klitsin coughed slightly in embarrassment: "I just said casually... In this case, let's make the decision using the traditional and ancient method."
"impossible."
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
Considering the importance of this theoretical model to the study of electrochemical interface structures, the Max Planck Society established an interdisciplinary research group, which brought together top scholars in the fields of mathematics, chemistry, and condensed matter physics to discuss this theoretical model.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
Facing the joint efforts of the two big guys, Klitsin coughed slightly in embarrassment: "I just said casually... In this case, let's make the decision using the traditional and ancient method."
"It's about being responsible for science."
"Heads are eliminated, tails continue." He took out a coin from his pocket and slapped it on the table. Professor Klitzing paused and continued slightly excitedly, "Of course, for the sake of fairness, I will also participate."
"From a mathematical perspective, there's nothing wrong with his process."
Faltins said slowly, as if he was telling Etel on purpose.
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
Eitel and Kriching breathed a sigh of relief.
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
For a Nobel Prize-level scholar, this kind of teaching and educating people seems a bit humiliating. However, in fact, many well-known scholars enjoy it and are willing to share their knowledge with young students.
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
"Of course it's our Institute of Mathematics."
If Professor Faltings thinks there is no problem, then basically in a mathematical sense, there should be no problem.
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
Because the voices were so consistent, both Faltins and Ertel were stunned for a moment after finishing speaking.
Kliting's heart moved slightly: "What do you mean?"
"I agree with your point of view, but the question is, which institute will issue the invitation?"
Seeing that the two of them were about to quarrel again, Professor Claus von Klitzing coughed slightly and tried to smooth things over with a helpless tone.
Klitzing looked at Eitel and asked: "What do you think about this theory?"
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
After thinking for a moment, Eitel said: "In my opinion, the problem is not big. But his theory is too obscure and difficult to understand. Even if we give a consistent evaluation, we cannot get the chemical community to accept his point of view. .”
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
Because the voices were so consistent, both Faltins and Ertel were stunned for a moment after finishing speaking.
Indifference to application is the consistent position of the Bourbaki school, and "glorious isolation" from other disciplines is usually regarded as noble. Although it is difficult to feel this chain of contempt within the discipline among younger mathematicians, this stubborn concept still exists among the older generation of mathematicians.
After leaving the classroom, Professor Eitel did not return directly to his office. Instead, he got into his car and rushed to the Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society in Berlin.
However, this is also a question that doesn’t need to be considered at all.
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
"We can send an invitation letter to Princeton, inviting Professor Lu to visit the Max Planck Institute for exchanges, and provide him with a platform to express his views to the entire theoretical chemistry community."
Kliting's heart moved slightly: "What do you mean?"
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
"I agree with your point of view, but the question is, which institute will issue the invitation?"
"That's enough, Mr. Faltings, we hope you will provide more constructive suggestions instead of listening to you ridicule us."
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
"Heads are eliminated, tails continue." He took out a coin from his pocket and slapped it on the table. Professor Klitzing paused and continued slightly excitedly, "Of course, for the sake of fairness, I will also participate."
"Of course it's our Institute of Physical Chemistry."
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
Tapping his index finger on the conference table, Klitsin asked thoughtfully: "What do you think is more appropriate?"
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
If Professor Faltings thinks there is no problem, then basically in a mathematical sense, there should be no problem.
Ertel exchanged glances with Klitzing and decided not to exchange a word with the stubborn old man until he had read the last part of the paper.
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
"We can send an invitation letter to Princeton, inviting Professor Lu to visit the Max Planck Institute for exchanges, and provide him with a platform to express his views to the entire theoretical chemistry community."
physicist tradition.
Of course, this kind of statement is not just about casually expressing opinions and taking sides.
However, this arrogant Germanic old man had this temper when he was at Princeton. After returning to his hometown in Germany, not only did he not change at all, but he became even worse.
What a shocking statement!
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
I have to say, this is a good idea.
The outstanding representative among them is probably the late number theory master Hardy. Apart from research, what this talented person loved to do most was to show off to others that he studied the purest and purest mathematics, and there was no mathematics in his research. "purpose" other than that, and be proud of it.
"Don't even think about it!"
physicist tradition.
Klitzing looked at Eitel and asked: "What do you think about this theory?"
Frowning slightly, Faltings said in an emphatic tone: "He is a mathematician."
Sitting down opposite Faltings, Ertel raised his eyebrows: "I don't agree with your point of view."
Klitsin nodded in agreement.
This is a very critical question.
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
Unfortunately, Hardy never dreamed that his research results would eventually be taken away by "cunning" application scientists, and would be widely used in computers and cryptography...
At this point, Eitel tapped the desk with the lesson plan.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
"I agree with your point of view, but the question is, which institute will issue the invitation?"
Ertel exchanged glances with Klitzing and decided not to exchange a word with the stubborn old man until he had read the last part of the paper.
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
"Of course it's our Institute of Mathematics."
"I will have the teaching assistant send the homework to your email. Now, get out of class is over."
New chemistry!
This is a very critical question.
"Professor, have you read the paper on the theoretical model of electrochemical structure interface that was recently published in JACS?"
"I agree with your point of view, but the question is, which institute will issue the invitation?"
"I agree with your point of view, but the question is, which institute will issue the invitation?"
I have to say, this is a good idea.
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
Of course, when Faltins said this, he did not mean that Lu Zhou was a second-rate mathematician, but he only expressed regret that he wasted his talent.
The Max Planck Society is not a top-down centralized research institution, and the various institutes are basically independent of each other.
Of course it's a bet.
"Heads are eliminated, tails continue." He took out a coin from his pocket and slapped it on the table. Professor Klitzing paused and continued slightly excitedly, "Of course, for the sake of fairness, I will also participate."
Seeing that the two were arguing, Kliting coughed slightly and put forward a compromise opinion.
However, this is also a question that doesn’t need to be considered at all.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
physicist tradition.
"impossible."
The two said almost in unison.
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
During the question-and-answer session at the end of the class, a student suddenly raised his hand and asked.
Looking at the students' reactions, Professor Ertel smiled.
The same goes for Professor Ettel, especially when he is troubled by a complex problem.
"Of course it's our Institute of Physical Chemistry."
There was an incredible exclamation in the classroom.
Professor Ertel paused for about two seconds, pushed up his reading glasses, and nodded.
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
However, this arrogant Germanic old man had this temper when he was at Princeton. After returning to his hometown in Germany, not only did he not change at all, but he became even worse.
"Of course it's our Institute of Mathematics."
Strictly speaking, this boss is an expert in the fields of algebraic geometry and arithmetic geometry, and functional analysis is not his research direction. However, as a master in the field of number theory, cross-directional research is not uncommon for him.
However, this is also a question that doesn’t need to be considered at all.
Frowning slightly, Faltings said in an emphatic tone: "He is a mathematician."
Of course, this kind of statement is not just about casually expressing opinions and taking sides.
Because the voices were so consistent, both Faltins and Ertel were stunned for a moment after finishing speaking.
In the field of electrochemistry, who else has more say than him
"That's enough, Mr. Faltings, we hope you will provide more constructive suggestions instead of listening to you ridicule us."
"I don't expect you to agree. Just like not everyone can appreciate ancient Greek sculptures, you can't expect a layman to understand the beauty of pure mathematics." Faltings said lightly.
"impossible."
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
Frowning slightly, Faltings said in an emphatic tone: "He is a mathematician."
Just last year at the Crafford Prize Award Ceremony, he said that there are only four mathematicians in the world who are expected to surpass him, and in his opinion Lu Zhou is the most promising.
After a long time, he threw the paper on the table and gave an evaluation that was barely acceptable.
At the same time, as one of the most influential mathematicians after Grothendieck and director of the Max Planck Institute for Mathematics, it is also necessary to have an understanding of other research directions.
Eitel looked at him with disbelief and argued rationally: "But what we are discussing now is a chemical problem."
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
"There are no ifs in science, but if you have to ask this..."
Eitel's eyebrows twitched fiercely.
"Have seen it, are there any questions?"
Professor Claus von Klitzing is a member of the Max Planck Institute for Condensed Matter Physics. Although he is not the director, he is the discoverer of the quantum Hall effect and a Nobel laureate.
In the field of electrochemistry, who else has more say than him
A paper recently published in JACS has caused widespread controversy in the chemical community. As one of the world's top academic research institutions, Max Planck is obliged to express its position on this paper.
"Have seen it, are there any questions?"
Seeing that the two were arguing, Kliting coughed slightly and put forward a compromise opinion.
"Heads are eliminated, tails continue." He took out a coin from his pocket and slapped it on the table. Professor Klitzing paused and continued slightly excitedly, "Of course, for the sake of fairness, I will also participate."
"Only second-rate mathematicians are interested in how to apply mathematics to solve real-world problems. In my opinion, this kind of thing has no value in reading at all."
However, the student didn't seem to be satisfied with this vague answer. He changed the question and continued to ask the question: "What if it is correct?"
Professor Ertel frowned, as if he was reluctant to comment on this topic, but in the end he relaxed his eyebrows and said in a relaxed tone, "If it is right, it means new chemistry."
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
Because the voices were so consistent, both Faltins and Ertel were stunned for a moment after finishing speaking.
"Since you can't make up your mind, why not just come to our Institute of Condensed Matter Physics..."
The two said almost in unison.
Kliting's heart moved slightly: "What do you mean?"
For a Nobel Prize-level scholar, this kind of teaching and educating people seems a bit humiliating. However, in fact, many well-known scholars enjoy it and are willing to share their knowledge with young students.
"Don't even think about it!"
"impossible."
"I'm not mocking you," Faltings glanced sharply at the paper, turned a page, and corrected him rigidly and stubbornly, "I was just stating the facts."
New chemistry!
The Max Planck Society is not a top-down centralized research institution, and the various institutes are basically independent of each other.
I have to say, this is a good idea.
"Don't even think about it!"
For a Nobel Prize-level scholar, this kind of teaching and educating people seems a bit humiliating. However, in fact, many well-known scholars enjoy it and are willing to share their knowledge with young students.
However, now, he was hesitant to change the four back to three.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
Klitzing looked at Eitel and asked: "What do you think about this theory?"
It is precisely for this reason that he is particularly cautious when dealing with this topic.
"Of course it's our Institute of Physical Chemistry."
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
Facing the joint efforts of the two big guys, Klitsin coughed slightly in embarrassment: "I just said casually... In this case, let's make the decision using the traditional and ancient method."
Eitel thought for a while and said in a casual tone: "My child, out of scientific rigor, I cannot answer this question for you for the time being."
Unfortunately, Hardy never dreamed that his research results would eventually be taken away by "cunning" application scientists, and would be widely used in computers and cryptography...
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
If someone else had said this, people here might not have taken it seriously at all. But the person who said this was Professor Ertel, the 2007 Nobel Prize winner and an expert in the field of solid surface chemistry!
In addition to being a professor at the University of Munich, he is director of the Fritz Haber Institute (Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry) of the Max Planck Society in Germany.
However, this is also a question that doesn’t need to be considered at all.
The student looked at him expectantly and asked, "Is it right?"
However, this arrogant Germanic old man had this temper when he was at Princeton. After returning to his hometown in Germany, not only did he not change at all, but he became even worse.
physicist tradition.
Eitel nodded: "There is nothing more appropriate than a lecture. The more difficult the theory is, the more direct communication is needed with the person."
However, this is also a question that doesn’t need to be considered at all.
However, this is also a question that doesn’t need to be considered at all.
Of course it's a bet.
"Only second-rate mathematicians are interested in how to apply mathematics to solve real-world problems. In my opinion, this kind of thing has no value in reading at all."
Facing the joint efforts of the two big guys, Klitsin coughed slightly in embarrassment: "I just said casually... In this case, let's make the decision using the traditional and ancient method."
"Heads are eliminated, tails continue." He took out a coin from his pocket and slapped it on the table. Professor Klitzing paused and continued slightly excitedly, "Of course, for the sake of fairness, I will also participate."
As a member of the research team and director of the Institute of Physical Chemistry, Ettel's opinions also represent the opinions of the Max Planck Institute of Physical Chemistry.
"Since you can't make up your mind, why not just come to our Institute of Condensed Matter Physics..."