As for what Zhou Chengfu said, he didn't take it to heart at all from the beginning.
Seeing the confident expression on Lu Zhou's face, Sheng Xianfu was slightly stunned.
"It's well written." Lu Zhou smiled and saw a page of the newspaper in his hand turned.
In addition to Academician Pan, there is also President Xu of JJTU.
In fact, Lu Zhou sometimes wonders if some weirdo with novel ideas will jump out to criticize him. Why is it that although he is so good at mathematics, he can even solve the existence and smoothness of NS equation solutions and even the problem of plasma turbulence? Help you solve a series of problems such as twisted molds, magnetic surface tearing, magnetic islands, etc.
As for Lu Zhou...
Results are always the best proof.
As for the central idea of the full text, in addition to criticizing the technical route of the stellarator, he also quietly deducted several "great achievements", "a waste of national resources", and "impacting the country's development of controllable nuclear fusion". high hat.
First of all, he poured cold water on it and pointed out from a popular science perspective that the plasma confinement time of 1 second is not novel at all in the field of controllable nuclear fusion.
When Lu Zhou found him and was about to discuss the control plan for the stellarator with the old academician, Principal Xu asked him about it as soon as they met.
It was written by Zhou Chengfu, head of the ITER Huaguo project team and head of the Huaguo International Nuclear Fusion Energy Program Execution Center.
"Your first priority now is to prepare for the experiment in August."
Lu Zhou smiled: "Are you scared?"
It's nothing more than trying to beat him before his "wings are full".
Even the Spiral Stone 7-X, which has an upgraded water-cooled divertor and improved control scheme, has only just touched the edge of this number.
"From WEGA to STAR, is the 4 billion spent worth it?" 》
The impact may be there, but relatively limited.
For example, Academician Pan.
After all, if you could keep your composure and know how to protect yourself wisely, you wouldn't have defected to him.
To put it simply, the main ideas of this scientific review article are nothing more than two points.
"What's going on with Zhou Chengfu?"
Of course, it was impossible for Lu Zhou not to know this, so he told Academician Pan not to worry about him.
Then he cleverly used the Spring and Autumn style of writing to highlight that the work done so far on the STAR stellarator project was nothing more than spending 4 billion RMB to buy a "second-hand" one from someone else.
It still has some use.
Do not establish arguments, only refute arguments. Selectively report facts that are beneficial to you and amplify them.
For example, a tokamak is a magnetic field coupling generated by an external magnetic field and a plasma current. This is equivalent to running tens of millions of amperes on a conductor that is unstable and subject to turbulence all the time.
However, for Lu Zhou, there was actually no need to do this.
Commentary articles signed by big names can influence high-level decision-making to some extent.
After a moment of silence, the corners of his mouth gradually curled up, rekindling his fighting spirit.
If it were a less famous scholar, he might have been beaten to death just based on the weight of this review article.
But then again, ordinary people are not worthy of Zhou Chengfu's humiliation to write such things.
…
After all, the country's investment in the field of controllable nuclear fusion is limited. If more is allocated to Lu Zhou, less will be allocated to him.
In fact, it’s not impossible to do it.
He knew very well what he should and shouldn't do at this time.
After hearing this for thirty minutes, Sheng Xianfu looked slightly moved and said with a confused look on his face.
As for why Academician Zhou did this, Lu Zhou could also guess.
But thinking about it, even Mr. Zhou would not use such ridiculous arguments to criticize his opponents.
Looking at Sheng Xianfu, who still had a somewhat unhappy expression, Lu Zhou slowly spoke.
Therefore, every experiment of the tokamak device is very cautious, and it is not without reason.
I have to say that Zhou Chengfu was indeed very experienced in this move.
The aura of the Nobel Prize is reflected here.
Soon, he saw the doorway inside.
Although the old academician has retired, he has always been paying attention to things in the industry.
If unresolved problems are considered black spots, then any technical route can identify them.
Serious problems such as twisted modes, magnetic surface tearing, and magnetic islands may lead to the collapse of the entire system. The consequences are far more dangerous than those of a stellarator, and may seriously damage the equipment.
The STAR project is now considered one of the key projects of Jinling University, and Lu Zhou is the pride of Jinling University. Mr. Pan may still have some scruples when facing Zhou Chengfu, but he does not accept this.
"Facts speak louder than words, and our results are the biggest fight back."
Seeing this, Lu Zhou raised his eyebrows with interest. He couldn't help but wonder what Academician Zhou was planning to do, so he continued reading along the main text of the article.
Even if Lu Zhou wanted to respond to this article, it would be difficult to refute him.
Of course, even if he himself doesn't care, there are still many people who care about him.
Seeing that Lu Zhou was not angry, but instead said lightly, "Well written," Sheng Xianfu couldn't help but said, "Aren't you angry?"
After seeing the article signed by Zhou Chengfu, his first reaction was to call Lu Zhou and persuade him not to act out of emotion. If you act impulsively at this time, you will play into Zhou Chengfu's hands.
"… How can it be."
Anticipating that he would ask this question, Lu Zhou smiled and said nonchalantly: "Do you think Academician Pan is angry?"
However, this so-called objectivity only lasted less than five hundred words.
What's more, this article is not a general editorial.
"I don't know... but can we just let it go?" Sheng Xianfu said angrily.
Academician Xu's temper is not as polite as that of Academician Pan.
Even the content of these five hundred words is just a preparation for this article with a predetermined position.
As for whether this is useful
Instead of discussing specific academic issues, they elevate academic issues or academic debates to moral, national or even political heights, and use the knowledge deficiencies and conservative ideas of the general public and even non-technocrats to incite their sense of justice and nationalism. Using emotions or admiration to criticize one's opponents can be said to be one of the common methods used by scholars to criticize each other.
The technical backbone of the STAR project team are all young and middle-aged scholars. Both Professor Li Changxia and Professor Sheng Xianfu are only in their thirties. It is normal for them to be impatient.
Even a great figure in international academic circles like Mr. Qiu has suffered from acclimatization when faced with the challenges of domestic academic circles.
"Next time, we will challenge for thirty minutes."
For academia, the problem of academic circles has been around for a long time.
"Thirty minutes... wouldn't it be too difficult for the STAR device?"
"Otherwise? Write a scientific review article to criticize Tokamak? And then offend most of the experts in the field of controllable nuclear fusion?" Putting the newspaper aside, Lu Zhou said casually, "Then What else do I do to research? I just report it to the newspaper."
Below this opinion-oriented title, the main body of the article takes about three paragraphs to briefly describe the past and present life of the STAR stellarator from an objective standpoint.