Ye Sibei stared at Meng Xin, she was almost dragged to the position by the staff.
After leaving the scene, she sat in the witness room and began a new round of waiting.
This time, she began to be afraid and began to tremble, because she understood that Meng Xin wanted to get what she wanted and prove what she was.
While Ye Sibei was waiting, Qin Nan and Zhang Yong continued chatting outside the corridor.
"When I first realized she was the victim, I actually had a grudge against her."
Qin Nan smoked a cigarette and looked at the wide square. He said in a dazed voice, "I think she is too weak. She didn't even say a word when she was bullied like this. Call the police. What is she afraid of?"
"I understand," Zhang Yong smiled, "I felt the same when I first became a policeman."
"At that time, I heard what she said in the video, and I realized that she might have a lot of suffering that I didn't know about. I felt that I should understand her better. No matter she was weak or cowardly, I should be more tolerant of her. I can't always tell her to be stronger and work harder, and then do nothing. So I didn't show any resentment towards her."
"and after?"
Qin Nan took a puff of cigarette, his face a little tired: "Later, until now, I suddenly understand that she didn't call the police not because she was weak, but because I was ignorant."
Qin Nan raised his head slightly and looked at the gloomy sky: "I have no idea what lies ahead."
"It was only when I really went through all this with her, when I was talked about, when I read all the nonsense on the Internet, when I was discouraged, and now I am worried about whether I can win, that I realized," Qin Nan laughed sarcastically, "If I had known that the future would be like this, I might not have had the courage to call the police."
"But she knew that this might happen in the future," Qin Nan paused, controlling his tone, "and finally called the police."
"Do you regret it?"
Zhang Yong glanced at him, and Qin Nan stopped talking.
I don’t know.
could firmly tell Ye Sibei not to regret it because knew that Ye Sibei had no way out.
But if you ask yourself, will you regret it after asking this question? I don’t know.
He was not a god, nor even a human being. He was cowardly, timid, and fearful, but he didn't want Ye Sibei to see it all.
"Sometimes I don't know," Qin Nan said in a hoarse voice, "what is the meaning of perseverance?"
"If we lose this case," Qin Nan turned to look at Zhang Yong, "what's the value of all the things we've gone through?"
Zhang Yong stopped talking and watched the dark clouds grow heavier.
"There have been several cases before."
For some reason, Zhang Yong suddenly brought up an irrelevant topic, took a deep puff of his cigarette, and described calmly: "This man committed crimes from 1993 to 2009. During this period, he committed 91 robberies, 23 thefts, and raped over 100 women. Do you know why he is so bold?"
"Why?"
"Don't tell the lawyers," Zhang Yong laughed sarcastically, with a bit of restrained anger, "During the crime process, some people dared to resist, and some people would report the case. You see, if everyone is silent about the criminals and holds the victims accountable, will these criminals be afraid?"
"Not at all." Zhang Yong approached Qin Nan and said affirmatively, "You can't expect bad guys to wake up one day and put down their butcher knives. If they commit crimes without restraint, they will just act recklessly."
"Ye Sibei called the police, and she insisted," Zhang Yong looked at Qin Nan, "This is the greatest deterrent to those who think they will not suffer any loss in the dark."
"What you have done is not unjust. Justice should never be absent. Although," Zhang Yong hesitated and said with some difficulty, "this road may not be so easy."
"My name is Zhao Chuchu, and I'm an employee of the Fuqiang Real Estate Sales Department."
After Zhao Chuchu went to court, Ye Nianwen felt a little relieved.
In fact, her testimony would be biased towards Ye Sibei.
Meng Xin watched Zhao Chuchu lower her head and recount what she saw that night. After she finished speaking, Meng Xin stood up again and asked questions.
"Your fiancé is Ye Sibei's younger brother, right?"
"yes."
Zhao Chuchu nodded, and Meng Xin continued: "Were you drunk that night?"
If she was drunk, the strength of her testimony would be greatly reduced. Zhao Chuchu shook her head decisively: "No."
Meng Xin nodded and continued: "So was Ye Sibei drunk that night?"
"drunk."
"How drunk are you? Can you recognize people?"
"She can recognize people and keeps talking."
Zhao Chuchu responded.
"Then when you separated, you testified that she was unconscious. To what extent was she unconscious?"
Zhao Chuchu was a little dazed as she listened to Meng Xin's words.
At that moment, her mind was full of online complaints about her.
"Ye Sibei is already unknown, but she still left him in the car. Who is she?"
"Rubbish, she did it on purpose, didn't she?"
…
She couldn't leave Ye Sibei, such an intelligent man, in the car since Ye Sibei trusted her so much.
If she was the cause of Ye Sibei's accident, then she would have to bear the responsibility immediately.
The moment she had to answer Meng Xin's question, she clearly realized that there could only be one person between Ye Sibei and her.
Either she admitted that she threw the unconscious Ye Sibei in the car, proving Ye Sibei's innocence, and she would be condemned by all.
Either she denies that Ye Sibei is unconscious and she is innocent, then Ye Sibei is likely to lose the case.
She didn't dare to reply. She was torn between inner thoughts and inner thoughts. Many voices echoed in her mind. Meng Xin observed her and called out again, "Zhao Chuchu?"
"Zhao Chuchu," the presiding judge noticed that she had been silent for too long and asked with concern, "Are you feeling unwell?"
Zhao Chuchu closed her eyes and made a decision in her heart. She had originally planned to completely crush it at that moment.
She has done enough for Ye Sibei.
She told herself that she had lost her job because of her, and had been humiliated and cursed by so many people because of her. She also had her own life. She did not have the courage, nor did she dare, to bear the accusations and ridicules of the world for Ye Sibei.
“I’m reminiscing.”
Zhao Chuchu opened her eyes and looked up at Meng Xin: "I don't remember the situation very clearly now, but I just remember that she was talking nonsense."
"Can you recognize the person?"
"She can recognize people. She doesn't talk much, but her logic is clear. She can also make phone calls clearly." Zhao Chuchu lowered her head. "That's why I put her in the car. I made an appointment with her in advance and asked her to call me when she got there."
She could recognize people and make clear phone calls, which meant that when she and Ye Sibei separated, Ye Sibei was conscious.
This is extremely unfavorable testimony to Ye Sibei, especially since the witness is a relative or friend who should be biased towards Ye Sibei, so the testimony is even more powerful.
Ye Nianwen stared at Zhao Chuchu, his breathing becoming heavier. Zhao Chuchu didn't even look at him, and the prosecutor in the prosecution seat frowned.
"During the whole process of Ye Sibei being drunk, do you feel that her drunkenness was getting worse?" Meng Xin continued to ask.
"No," Zhao Chuchu answered fluently after making up her mind, "After she vomited, I helped her sit next to me. She was a little excited and kept talking. She kept talking like that and it didn't get any worse."
"She used to be like this after drinking, right?"
"right."
"How much does she usually drink?"
"About two taels."
"How much did you drink that day?"
"Less than two taels."
"In other words, isn't this actually the kind of drinking that can make her completely lose consciousness?"
"I have no idea."
"Then," Meng Xin asked the last question, "did you tell her that wearing a condom on her own initiative could increase her chances of survival if she was raped?"
Hearing this question, Zhao Chuchu remained silent.
She said this to Ye Sibei, and only Ye Sibei and she knew it. Meng Xin would ask this question, so it must be Ye Sibei who told her.
Ye Sibei was not unaware of her recent online scandals, and he was also aware of what she had been through.
This was just a private remark she made. Ye Sibei knew how much of an impact it would have on her reputation if it became known to others in public.
But Ye Sibei still said he was here.
She felt that she and Ye Sibei were like two little animals put into a narrow cage, with others forcing them and telling them that only the two of them could survive.
So they sold each other out and protected each other's rights.
Zhao Chuchu smiled, and tears appeared in her eyes.
"Yes."
She said hoarsely: "I didn't say that."
Ye Nianwen's hand trembled slightly as he held the pen. He stared at Zhao Chuchu, unable to believe that Zhao Chuchu's final testimony was like this.
There was nothing more to ask after this, so Meng Xin nodded, indicating that he had finished asking questions. After he sat down, a prosecutor at the prosecution seat requested to ask questions.
"When you were taking the statement, you clearly said that Ye Sibei was unconscious when you got off the car. Why do you change your statement now and say that she can recognize people and make phone calls clearly?"
"I thought that being unable to stop talking was a sign of unconsciousness."
"So what exactly do you mean by talking nonsense?"
"She can say things that she normally wouldn't. For example, she talks about the family situation, she's upset, and so on."
The prosecutor nodded and sat down with a frown.
After both parties finished questioning, Zhao Chuchu was taken away. During this time, she didn't dare to raise her head, or even look at Ye Nianwen again.
After the witnesses have finished questioning, they start to present the evidence. The entire court investigation phase ends and the court debate phase begins.
Rape cases occur in closed environments. In addition to objective biological evidence, more information about the parties' consent is based on confessions from both parties, witness testimonies, and various common sense inferences.
The deadlock in this case lies in the fact that in the statements of the victim and the suspect, neither side has enough evidence to testify to their own words.
Fan Jiancheng has evidence to prove that Ye Sibei showed intimidation and threatened him;
Ye Sibei was persuaded to drink in an unconventional way, and was indeed drunk, which might have caused him to become unconscious;
The environment in which they took place was a closed one, which was enough to make it possible for Ye Sibei to be coerced;
Lin Feng's testimony also proved that Ye Sibei's mental state at the time was not the attempted blackmail as Fan Jiancheng said;
Ye Sibei called the police as soon as possible. Ye Sibei and Fan Jiancheng had never been in a relationship where they were lovers or had any possibility of sexual intercourse. It is common sense to infer that this was most likely rape.
But at the same time, Ye Sibei's behavior that goes against common sense, such as being short of money, taking the initiative to wear a condom, fully cooperating during the process, repeatedly calling the police, and having discrepancies between his confession and objective evidence such as photos and recordings, also arouses suspicion.
This could indeed be a honey trap that she wrote, directed, and acted out herself. She deceived Lin Feng and set a trap for Fan Jiancheng.
"She showed no signs of resistance during the whole process, and even actively cooperated. She said she resisted, but in fact the scratches she left were on my client's left shoulder. Given the location and direction of the scratches, hugging is the most likely cause of such scratches. Not only was it not resistance, it could even be said to be proactive."
Meng Xin raised his own doubts.
"According to the victim's confession, this was entirely due to coercion. Not resisting and actively cooperating are no way to prove that the victim was willing. On the contrary, the suspect took the drunk person to a confined space where he could not resist and performed sexual acts in a relationship where the possibility of sexual relations was extremely low. It is reasonable to infer that the possibility of coercion is far greater than voluntary."
"If Ye Sibei is right, why is there such a big contradiction between her description of the case and the physical evidence? She said she only made one call, but the actual number was shown to be two. She said she did not see the suspect, but there are photos of her with her eyes open. She was not blindfolded the whole time. Her confession is completely inconsistent with the physical evidence."
"Fan Jiancheng may have deleted the phone call after making the first call, and the photo may have been taken when he was drunk and unconscious," the prosecutor countered. "If Ye Sibei made the call at the time, Ye Sibei was completely sober, she knew she was calling, and she watched Fan Jiancheng take the photo with her eyes open. How could she not know about the existence of this call and this photo? She should have lied more and said that this photo was the key evidence proving that the victim was unconscious at the time."
"She usually drinks only two taels of alcohol. All the witnesses, including herself, stated that the amount of alcohol she drank that day could not allow a normal person to reach the level of complete loss of consciousness as she said. Zhao Chuchu also testified that when they parted, Ye Sibei was able to fully recognize people, make phone calls, and speak logically. Under normal circumstances, she could not have reached the level of unconsciousness that the procuratorate believes. The procuratorate's speculation of this possibility is a guess without an objective basis."
"There is no direct evidence to prove that the victim threatened the suspect. It was just the suspect's unilateral confession. We even have additional audio evidence to prove that the victim insisted on suing when faced with bribes from the company. If she wanted money, she would have changed her confession long ago."
"That audio clip was recorded by the victim herself, which proves that she has a strong sense of legal protection. This is supporting evidence. If she really intended to illegally threaten our client, she would not give me the opportunity to preserve the evidence..."
The two sides fought back and forth, engaging in a fierce battle over evidence, witness testimony, and confessions.
Both sides have irrefutable evidence and can only look for flaws in the witness testimonies.
Compared with Fan Jiancheng, the contradiction between Ye Sibei's confession and physical evidence is greater.
She said she only made one call, but there were actually two call records.
She said she resisted, but the only trace of resistance seemed more like that left by intimate contact.
She said that she had no consciousness at all and was blindfolded when she opened her eyes. In fact, it was almost impossible for her to drink so much that she completely lost consciousness. Zhao Chuchu's temporary supplementary testimony further proved that she should have been sober throughout the whole process and it was unlikely that she had completely blacked out for a period of time as she said.
There was no mention of condom use in her confession, although there were actually condom casings at the scene;
She said that Zhao Chuchu taught her to carry condoms, but Zhao Chuchu flatly denied it...
At the end of the case, both parties made their final summary.
The prosecutor stood up first: "In this case, the suspect and the victim were in a superior-subordinate relationship. Before the incident, there was no ambiguous words or actions, and there was no common sense for sexual relations. On the day of the incident, there was abnormal persuasion to drink at the table. As a superior, the suspect did not stop it and indulged in persuading people to drink. There is a possibility of criminal preparation. From the surveillance and witness testimony, it is proved that the parties were drunk at the time. The suspect took the drunken victim alone to the reed field on the outskirts of the city, which formed an absolutely overwhelming and closed environment for the victim, enough to make the victim feel that his life was in danger. The victim was coerced and violated her will to cooperate with the suspect to complete the sexual assault. After the incident, the victim called the police immediately and took the initiative to ask for a rape identification. Although she was determined, she changed her statement and withdrew the case despite social resistance. This is also common sense. Combined with the biological identification of semen stains and dandruff, our court believes that the suspect Fan Jiancheng used coercion to violate the victim's will and forced sexual intercourse. His behavior violated Article 236 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China. The crime is clear and he should be held criminally responsible for rape. "
After the prosecutor finished speaking, Meng Xin stood up and said, "In this case, the victim used my client's position in the company to falsely issue a salary certificate in order to buy a house for her brother before the incident. Later, her husband discovered this because of the loan, and a rift occurred between the victim and her husband. It can be inferred that the victim had a certain private relationship with my client in the past, and was in a state of extreme lack of money, which gave her an objective motive to falsely accuse my client. In the case, the defendant's confession and the physical evidence were basically consistent, with only flaws, while the victim's confession and the witness testimony were consistent. There are flaws in the oral and physical evidence, and the strong witness Lin Feng himself is biased against the case, which reduces the credibility of his testimony. The prosecution has no direct evidence to convict our client, and it is more based on common sense inference. From common sense, the victim took the initiative to bring condoms on the day of the incident, and the amount of alcohol he drank was not enough to reach the level of unconsciousness. He claimed to be completely unconscious. After being drunk, he knew the route between Zhao Chuchu and his residence, and he would definitely be left alone when the two of them were on the road. Under such circumstances, he pointed out that our client— An older man sent her home. Although he called the police after the incident, he did not directly state that there was sexual assault. He waited a few days before calling the police again. All these behaviors are not in line with common sense. On the other hand, my client's confession is more consistent with the physical evidence and has clearer logic. Therefore, we believe that there is insufficient evidence in this case and the facts are wrongly determined. Our client should be acquitted. "
After Meng Xin finished speaking, it was finally Ye Nianwen's turn to speak. At this time, Ye Nianwen already roughly knew the ending.
I stood up, not knowing what to say. The prosecution had already done its best, and as a lawyer in the ancillary civil lawsuit, I could not put forward many strong opinions.
She stood there with red eyes for a long time before she spoke hoarsely, "Ye Sibei is my sister. She has always been a very careful person."
Everyone was looking at him, he raised his head and said slowly, "This has been rationally argued in the court. Morning is the softest time of life."
"She loves beauty and doesn't even dare to show her arms. She likes to wear makeup, but she never dares to wear gaudy makeup. She almost never goes out at night. Most of the time, my dad and my brother-in-law pick her up. The suit she was wearing when she was victimized was a company uniform. She always said that every time she went to the company, even in summer, she had to wear a windbreaker. So on the day she called the police, she told the police that she wanted a windbreaker because, for her, this windbreaker was a kind of safety protection. Now that she had the windbreaker, she asked the police for it, actually because she was asking for help."
As Ye Nianwen spoke, tears could not stop falling.
I know, there are already more than twenty people involved. As a lawyer, I shouldn't lose my composure in public.
But he couldn't stop, his voice was trembling and filled with tears.
"She called the police, but my mom tried to stop her. I also tried to stop her because as a lawyer, I know how hurtful such cases are to the parties involved. So she called the police and denied that she did so. But my sister finally decided to call the police again, not because of money or extortion, but just to seek justice."
"Your Honor," Ye Nianwen looked at the judge pleadingly with tears in her eyes, "For ordinary people, being able to sue is already a great courage. I think justice should not let this kind of courage disappear. She should get justice."
The presiding judge looked at me quietly, and I seemed to be moved. However, after a long while, I spoke: "Justice should not destroy any courage, and should try to make everyone get justice. But judges are not gods. We can only rely on the law and do our best to give everyone fairness."
After the presiding judge finished speaking, he announced a recess and all judges entered the deliberation room to discuss the final result.
Qin Nan and Zhang Yong also returned to the court entrance. Zhang Yong looked relaxed: "After the trial, do you plan to stay in South City or go somewhere else?"
"Look at Sibei."
Qin Nan smiled, and Zhang Yong was a little surprised: "Actually, I am particularly curious."
"Um?"
"If Ye Sibei hadn't married you, would you have treated someone else like this?"
Qin Nan smiled with some dismay.
"How can it be?"
"After more than a year of marriage, is your friendship still so deep?"
Zhang Yong asked: "You didn't know each other before?"
"Yes."
Qin Nan shook his head: "Yes."
"Really? How many times have you been there?"
"No. 7 Middle School."
"Well," Zhang Yong sighed, "it's still possible that you have some alumni. Isn't No. 2 Middle School far from No. 7 Middle School?"
"right."
As the two were talking, more voices came from around them. Qin Nan heard a noise not far away. He turned around and looked towards the source of the noise, only to find that the witnesses were being escorted in. Ye Sibei was among them. She stood not far away with red eyes and tiredness.
Qin Nan looked at her quietly. She forced a smile and was about to turn around when she saw the door of the court suddenly open.
The courtroom was filled with people, and the crowd separated them.
The first one to arrive was Meng Xin, with a unhappy and indifferent look on his face. Behind him, Fan Jiancheng was full of joy. He rushed to his wife outside the door, hugged her and children, and talked excitedly with his family.
Zhao Shuhui seemed extremely happy. Finally, under Fan Jiancheng's comfort, she cried softly. Then she turned to the court and shouted at the reporters outside.
"Not guilty!"
She shouted until she was hoarse, crying and screaming: "My husband is innocent! Did you hear me? My husband is innocent!"
Ye Sibei was stunned for a moment. She couldn't see anything. Then she looked at the prosecutors. They stood in front of her and bowed their heads and said, "I'm sorry."
Ye Sibei stared at them blankly. She was speechless. The prosecutor kept silent with her. After a long silence, she finally left.
Qin Nan and Ye Sibei's parents came over and stood behind Ye Sibei. After waiting for a long time, Ye Nianwen came out with red eyes.
Huang Guifen stepped forward eagerly: "How is it? What's the result?"
Ye Nianwen didn't say anything, Huang Guifen suddenly became anxious, she grabbed Ye Nianwen's arm and cried, "Speak! Speak!"
"Don't be impatient!"
Ye Ling pulled Huang Guifen away and yelled, "Slow down! Nianwen," Ye Ling looked at Ye Nianwen with concern, "Did you win or lose?"
"I'm sorry..." Ye Nianwen started to cry as soon as she opened her mouth, "I'm sorry... Sister... I'm sorry..."
Ye Sibei was silent.
She felt as if she was suddenly pushed into water. It was the coffin that she had dreamt of countless times. Water was pouring in. This time, she couldn't even escape. It was as if someone had closed the coffin lid and knocked on it.
"Let's go back first."
Qin Nan was the first to react: "There are too many people, let's go back first."
"Yes," Zhang Yong came up after hearing Qin Nan's words, and he was much calmer. "Ye Sibei needs to take some time off. I'll take you out first."
When Ye Ling heard this, he took a deep breath and supported Huang Guifen, who was stunned. He nodded and said, "Go back first."
People were supporting each other as they walked toward the court and opened the door, the drizzle hitting their faces.
Reporters wearing raincoats swarmed over and asked Ye Sibei, "Will you appeal again?"
"What do you think of Mr. Fan's not guilty verdict?"
"Are you accusing Mr. Fan for money or for some other reason?"
"Someone on the Internet revealed that you are a mistress who failed to get promoted and is seeking revenge. What do you think?"
…
Countless embarrassing and annoying questions came up, and Ye Sibei was protected in Qin Nan's arms, moving forward numbly.
Not far away, Fan Jiancheng's wife was yelling at the reporter: "I said she was blackmailing our Jiancheng for money. Our Jiancheng has always been our husband and father. He is kind to everyone."
Hearing these words, Huang Guifen suddenly stopped.
Ye Sibei looked up blankly, and saw Huang Guifen screaming and rushing over: "I'll tear you apart!"
The elderly man pushed through the crowd and grabbed Fan Jiancheng's wife by the hair. Her body was sluggish and a little fat, and she immediately screamed and started pushing her.
The man next to Zhao Shuhui pushed Huang Guifen, and Ye Nianwen yelled, "Don't touch my mother!"
As soon as Ye Nianwen stepped forward, Fan Xiaomen immediately took action. Ye Ling stumbled forward, and Qin Nan also rushed over.
The crowd screamed and two people started to wrestle with each other.
The rain was getting heavier and heavier, the sky was getting dark, and Ye Sibei watched all this numbly.
She watched her always cowardly and elderly father being pushed to the ground. She watched her mother, who had high blood pressure, high blood lipids and half white hair, wrestling with Zhao Shuhui.
She watched her bookish brother, whom she had never fought with since childhood, being pinned to the ground and beaten with fists. She watched Qin Nan, like a helpless lion surrounded by people, roaring and struggling.
They were like wild animals trapped in a cage, fighting hard.
The rain splashed on her face. She raised her head tremblingly and looked at Fan Jiancheng in the crowd.
He led a few men to wrestle with Qin Nan, punching Qin Nan in the face. He seemed to have finally vented his hatred, cursing, "Fuck you, I'm going to beat you up today."
.
has not received any punishment.
She had put so much effort into this journey, she had almost destroyed herself, but she couldn't let herself be destroyed along with her.
This was like the countless resistances and struggles in her life.
In the past, she could tell herself that it was because she wasn’t working hard enough or being brave enough.
But what about now
She tried hard, she fought, she struggled, and as everyone said, she went against the current and fought hard.
But what is the result
Why, she had never done anything wrong, but had to suffer this disaster, while those evildoers could still live in such a high position
Something suddenly collapsed in her heart. She looked at the people walking in the heavy rain and finally regained her senses. She screamed, grabbed the umbrella in her hand, rushed over, and hit Fan Jiancheng hard on the head!
Fan Jiancheng turned around and slapped her, but she bit his hand.
She seemed to be fighting for her life, and the fierce light in her eyes frightened Fan Jiancheng so much that he retreated unconsciously. However, the severe pain in her hand made her angry, and she punched Ye Sibei. Qin Nan rushed over to hold Fan Jiancheng down. At this time, the police finally arrived and dragged them away.
Ye Sibei was dragged away. He took half a step back and just as he loosened his grip a little, she rushed forward desperately.
Several men couldn't hold her down. She would beat and bite anyone who tried to stop her. She stared at Fan Jiancheng and tried to grab him like a madman.
"Let me go, I'll kill you, I'll kill you!"
She tried to push away the bailiffs who came to stop her, and there was nothing left in her eyes, she only looked at—
She was going to hell, and she was going to drag that guy with her.
Injustice must be repaid and harm must be repaired.
"Let me go! Let me go! I want justice, I just want justice!"
She kicked and punched and struggled hard.
She fell and stood up again, backed away and rushed forward again.
She rushed around, yelling and shouting. No one had ever seen her so ferocious. She was like a wolf or a lion. She saw everything in her eyes but staring at Fan Jiancheng.
The surrounding police came to pull her and stop her, until finally someone hugged her from behind.
"Sibei, stop it." He let her hit and kick him.
She didn't even look at who it was and struggled desperately: "Let me go, let me go!"
"Sibei!"
That person shouted loudly, and she realized who it was, and finally came to her senses.
The man knelt on the ground with her, and hugged her from behind, as if he wanted to embed her into his life.
Huang Guifen, Ye Ling, and Ye Nianwen still tried to rush forward, but many people pulled them back, and many people stood in front of them.
There were mountains and seas of people all around, and they surrounded these people, trying to stop them from doing anything crazy.
Ye Sibei was slammed by the heavy rain, looking at this scene that seemed to bury their whole world.
She was held in Qin Nan's arms, crying and hunching over.
"ah!!!!!"
“Ahhhh!!!”
She watched Fan Jiancheng being escorted away in a certain direction, screaming and crying.
For the first time, she felt that she was finally completely defeated by this world.
There will be no more expectations, no hope, no beauty, no struggle.
The candle in the soul that flickered in the darkness was finally extinguished completely after a gust of wind.