"Look, this scene, exchanging business cards and adding WeChat to each other, can completely prove that Tang Li and Lu Shuisheng met for the first time on the day of the surveillance video! However, comparing the time, Tian Mu had already been in the I have worked for Lu Shuisheng, so Lu Shuisheng has already been sending money to Tang Li."
Bai Duanduan paused the screen, and concluded: "Since Tian Mu claimed that Tang Li and Lu Shuisheng had an extramarital affair, and the large monthly income was the maintenance fee paid by Lu Shuisheng, how can they explain why Tang Li and Lu Shuisheng Shuisheng hasn't met him yet, but the 'nurturing fee' has already been paid in a few months in advance? Could it be that Lu Shuisheng is unpredictable and knows that he will have an extramarital affair with Tang Li in the future?"
Bai Duandan smiled: "Because of this surveillance video, the other party's timeline is completely vulnerable, and look." She zoomed in on the paused picture, "This angle clearly captured Tang Li's phone screen, she The QR code is very clear, I tried it just now, and I can even add it to the other party’s WeChat after scanning, it is indeed her right, she can’t even deny it.”
This unexpected turn of events lifted Ji Lin's spirit.
Obviously, Tian Mu had never introduced his beautiful wife to Lu Shuisheng before pretending to be an "extramarital affair", so Tang Li probably had never met Lu Shuisheng before he faked dating photos of the extramarital affair, so he had no idea what her husband was doing A mysterious company in which a mysterious boss serves.
"So there is a high probability that Tang Li went to the gym to wait for Tian Mu that day, but unexpectedly, he was bumped into by Lu Shuisheng. The two did not know each other at the time, because Tang Li was beautiful, and Lu Shuisheng, as a boss, couldn't help but want to strike up a conversation. Let's flirt, Tang Li probably had some turbulent thoughts in his heart, so he exchanged contact information, and then there was a scene in the surveillance."
With this explanation, all the clues are correct.
"I will continue to improve the chain of evidence!"
Bai Duanduan was full of fighting spirit, and after reporting to Ji Lin, Ji Lin was responsible for communicating the good news to Xie Miao, and Bai Duanduan took the computer back to his seat, and the arbitral tribunal was going to reconvene in a few days. Absolutely nothing can go wrong.
—
In Bai Duanduan's tension and anticipation, three days later, the arbitral tribunal finally opened again.
This time, Bai Duanduan and Ji Lin were fully prepared, and they also anticipated the solution to any possible excuses from the other party. Bai Duanduan didn't want to repeat the negligence of last time, and Ji Lin was also ready to fight. After all, this was the first time he and Lin Hui had a direct confrontation, and he didn't want to lose. Xie Miao also attached great importance to this hearing, and brought the relevant staff to the scene in person.
Compared with Ji Lin Bai Duanduan's uplifting spirit, Lin Hui seemed a bit out of shape. Although he was still wearing a meticulous suit, his complexion was not very good. There were two deep dark circles under his eyes, and there were some spots in his eyes. Bloodshot, he looked a little haggard, but his client, Tian Mu, was in a good state of mind and relaxed.
As co-defendants, Tang Li and Lu Shuisheng naturally also attended the arbitration. Probably in order to set off the bleakness after the cheating in marriage was discovered, Tang Li did not dress up to attend. He was dressed in plain and elegant clothes, and did not wear heavy makeup on his face, but his complexion was still quite good, and he did not look like someone who had marital problems at all. Lu Shuisheng was also relaxed, with his usual composure on his face, and when he saw Bai Duanduan, he even smiled at her.
They definitely knew that Bai Duanduanji had gone to call the gym to monitor, but they probably boasted that their previous layout was excellent, there was absolutely no negligence, and there was no trace of panic on their faces.
This group of people really don't want to die until they meet the Yellow River and don't cry when they don't see the coffin.
Bai Duanduan stabilized his mind and began to produce key evidence on his side.
"After our verification, Mr. Tian Mu and Mr. Lu Shuisheng coincidentally signed up for membership in the same high-end fitness club, Eggers, and there are relevant surveillance videos showing that they were exercising in the gym on the same day..."
When Bai Duanduan said this, Tian Mu was still noncommittal. The calmness on his face could almost confirm Bai Duanduan. He was laughing at himself in his heart. After all, two people registered for membership and fitness in the same gym, which meant nothing at all. A little evidence can't shake the foundation of "extramarital affairs" and "iron evidence".
"Of course." Bai Duanduan changed the subject, "These really don't explain much, but when we checked the surveillance video, we found some interesting things, which are of great significance to prove this case."
With the consent of the arbitrator, Bai Duanduan played another video in court.
Tian Mu didn't take it seriously at first, even though Tang Li appeared on the screen in the reception room, he didn't have too much emotion, his face was still very relaxed, but Tang Li beside him began to fidget a little, as the video progressed , her face became more and more ugly, and on the other side, Lu Shuisheng finally couldn't laugh anymore.
Because soon, Lu Shuisheng also appeared on the screen, and then everything progressed as Bai Duanduan had seen countless times before. Tang Li and Lu Shuisheng put their heads together happily and ambiguously, whispering in a low voice. After a while, they exchanged contact information as if speculative. After that, Lu Shuisheng left...
After a while, Tian Mu appeared on the screen, and then Tang Li took his hand, and the two left together. It was nothing at all, but compared to Tang Li's intimacy with Lu Shuisheng before, and seeing her treatment of Tian Mu, it was indeed not very pleasant. It's a treat, although physically she and Tian Mu are closer, but when she faces Tian Mu, she doesn't have the elation and excitement when she was facing Lu Shuisheng just now, but she is calm and looks like a guest...
Bai Duanduan paused the playback of the video. She looked at Tian Mu confidently and calmly: "Mr. Tian Mu, we sympathize with your experience. It seems that you and your wife, Ms. Tang Li, do not have much in common. About It’s really not speculative, and Ms. Tang Li can see that she has more common topics with Mr. Lu Shuisheng when she first met him. From these clues, we really understand your desire to divorce."
Bai Duanduan didn't care about Tian Mu's gloomy and blackened face and his eyes staring at him, and continued without fear of death: "However, although your wife and Mr. Lu Shuisheng did have a little contact behind your back, but time However, it does not match the statement you provided us and the monthly payment records. This timeline, do you think you can explain it to us? How could the payment come first? Two people know each other after the disaster Woolen cloth?"
Not to mention Tian Mu, everyone on the other side obviously didn't expect this kind of development. Lin Hui didn't know such details at all.
Tang Li's face turned completely pale. She never thought that her unintentional teasing would be shown in full detail by the surveillance camera. During that time, she had some opinions on Tian Mu, because the few Internet celebrity sisters she knew were obviously not as good-looking as she was, and they were not as popular as herself. Mu was several times richer than himself, but he was hanged on Tian Mu's crooked neck tree because of his married status. As a result, he sacrificed so much, but Tian Mu obviously didn't give him the corresponding "compensation". He wanted to buy a bag worth more than 100,000 yuan, but he always had to babble, he was not at all cheerful, obviously the most popular now, but Tian Mu, a chubby passerby with his looks, was really ashamed to take pictures of him...
Under this trend of mentality, Tang Li was very unbalanced during that time. Tian Mu hadn't worked for several months. Li's account is closed, but Tang Li still feels uneasy. He went to the gym to wait for Tian Mu that day. It needs affirmation and compliments from the outside world, and at this time, Lu Shuisheng appeared in a timely manner...
He is young and vigorous, with the maturity and experience that a man of this age should have. He speaks impeccably and humorously, with a sweet mouth and a high EQ. He made himself happy after just a few simple chats.
Facing such a man, Tang Li didn't refuse on a whim. She concealed her married status and exchanged contact information with him, but unexpectedly, she made a big mistake...
Tian Mu obviously didn't know these details in the surveillance before this. He immediately shifted his gaze to Tang Li, his face was full of gloom and anger that he was trying to suppress. He even forgot that he was still in the arbitration court , still defending that he did not violate the non-compete obligation.
His eyes were fixed on Tang Li, and his voice trembled with anger: "Tang Li, so you really did this behind my back."
Lin Hui immediately wanted to prevent his client from engaging in a suicidal dispute. After all, under Tian Mu's anger, who knew he would say something unfavorable to him.
However, it was too late. Pretending to be cuckolded is not the same emotional shock as finding out that one might really be cuckolded. Although Tian Mu's expression is still normal, he seems to be on the verge of collapse and explosion. edge over.
He looked at Tang Li, then at Lu Shuisheng, gritted his teeth and said, "You guys are really wonderful!"
Almost after finishing this sentence, Tian Mu had a sign of losing control of his emotions. He began to laugh like no one else was there, with a painful ironic expression on his face: "Tang Li, do you really want to divorce me?"
Tang Li panicked now, and she didn't care about what the lawyer told her earlier, she subconsciously began to explain: "Husband, listen to me, it's not like this, I just exchanged contact information with him, but after that I and He really didn’t contact him, he only said two or three sentences, and he didn’t talk to him after that, really! I can show you all the chat records on my mobile phone, it’s absolutely true, I just... I just added it casually that day when I was bored It’s just him, there’s nothing else, don’t think too much, it’s just a new friend…”
"Oh, you told me not to think too much? Then since you are Guangming Zheng and you have met a friend, why didn't you mention that when I brought Lu Shuisheng out and asked you to pose for a photo of 'cheating'? Have you ever added WeChat?" Tian Mu's face was deeply gloomy, "You have no ghosts in your heart, will you tell me? Now I finally know what happened to your embarrassment when I introduced Lu Shuisheng to you. I see and It's not embarrassing for him to pose for a photo, but the embarrassing thing is that the one who flirts is someone your husband knows?"
"It's not like that, it's not..."
Tang Li was crying, but Lu Shuisheng calmed down a lot. He stopped Tian Mu's words almost angrily: "Tian Mu, what nonsense are you talking about? What about arranging a small composition? What do you mean by posing for those photos?"
Obviously, until now, Lu Shuisheng is still trying his best to save the situation, trying to remind Tian Mu to understand the overall situation with his arrogance.
It's a pity that even a man can't bear this kind of thing, not to mention that Tian Mu is obviously holding his breath in his heart. It's good that Lu Shuisheng didn't speak, but when he spoke, Tian Mu looked more excited and angry. He almost yelled at Lu Shuisheng: "shut up!"
Lu Shuisheng pursed his lips, frowned, his face was gloomy, but he didn't speak any more.
The good arbitration tribunal, but now it seems to be Tian Mu and Tang Li's marriage tribunal.
"Tang Li, now, let me tell you the truth. In fact, I peeked at your mobile phone chat records half a year ago. At that time, you had a few male netizens. I don't know the number, but it's easy to talk to you. Ambiguous, you still call you baby, but you never correct it, people greet you, obviously have other ideas, but you still continue to chat with them, and one of them even gave you a bag."
Tian Mu closed his eyes: "At that time, I was still in the game with Wen Wen, busy working on a game project, and I did work a lot of overtime, and I left you out in the cold, so I chose to turn a blind eye at that time, thinking that I would spend more time with you. Accompanying you, our relationship will not change, but I didn't expect that your flirting is a kind of inertia... "
Tang Li was in a guilty mood at first, but she also became a little annoyed when Tian Mu publicly accused her: "What is flirting? Is it a habit? I just added someone's contact information. Did I do anything? Did I meet someone? Did I step on two boats? Ask Mr. Lu yourself, what happened to me and him afterwards? Yes, I am not good, I sometimes feel irritable and want to be coaxed, but you Is it okay? You stay at home all day, except for your work, you have no time to accompany me at all, that’s fine, you have no time and money, but you work there all day, and I don’t see much more income Ah? I just don't know what you're busy with all day long!"
This marriage has been going on to this day, and Tang Li also has a lot of dissatisfaction with Tian Mu in his heart. Now that Tian Muyu has died and even made such accusations regardless of the occasion, Tang Li also broke the pot: "I have never done anything that is actually sorry for you. It was you who put me in such a dangerous situation."
As soon as this was mentioned, Tang Li felt aggrieved: "Because of your own problems, you violated some contract and said that you will face huge compensation, so you dragged me to be your back, and asked me and Mr. Lu to pretend to be an extramarital affair. Did you consider me when you took photos of extramarital affairs? Do you know that I am an Internet celebrity? Once anyone here has a bad mouth and publishes these things on the Internet, how will I behave in the future? No People will care that I pretended to have an extramarital affair to help you cover up. They will only think that I am really having an extramarital affair. Do you know how ugly these people on the Internet will scold you? Tian Mu, you always think you are good to me, yes I tolerate and dote on me, but look for yourself, how can you push me to such a dangerous cliff? If this matter is revealed, what will I do for the rest of my life!"
Tang Li became more and more aggrieved as she spoke, and she actually burst into tears on the spot. After she finished accusing Tian Mu, she looked at Bai Duanduan full of resentment: "And you, you rubbish lawyer who will do whatever it takes to win the lawsuit and trample on other people's feelings at will. You even approached me by concealing your identity." She questioned Bai Duanduan, "Don't you feel ashamed? Do people like you have friends? I treat you as a friend, and I don't hide anything from you. What happened? In the end, you used me to stab our family, are you human?"
Now in such a scene, the matter has progressed to the point of no end, Lu Shuisheng's face is ugly, Lin Hui's expression is helpless, Tian Mu is angry and excited, Tang Li is crying and making noise.
The arbitrator repeatedly reiterated the issue of court discipline several times, but this farce was too full of twists and turns, everyone was caught in their own emotions, and no one paid attention to the arbitrator's statement.
A non-compete dispute has turned into an ethical drama.
In any case, even if there is no further contact with those men, to some extent, Tang Li has been shaken in this marriage, and even tried to cheat mentally. Facing Tian Mu, she is not without flaws, even if she accuses him However, when facing Bai Duanduan, she felt that she was very righteous, so now she is glaring at Bai Duanduan, trying to vent all the unwillingness and depression she has suffered during these days and today to Bai Duan carry on.
"A person like you who has exhausted all kinds of tricks is only worthy of having no friends. I curse you not to die well. Whether it is family, friendship or love in this life, I hope you will not meet anyone who is sincere to you. A bitch like you will not Terrible!"
Ji Lin immediately pulled his face down. He looked at Tang Li and was about to open his mouth, but Bai Duanduan stopped him before he could defend himself.
She patted Ji Lin's hand lightly, her tone calm and composed: "It's okay, I'll do it myself."
As a female lawyer, if someone sprayed her, of course she sprayed it back.
Tang Li's face was full of anger and distorted at the moment, with pear blossoms and tears on her face. In her heart, Bai Duanduan and Ji Lin must be the instigators of all the current difficulties. After all, if Bai Duanduan hadn't been holding on Forensic recording, she will not be pushed out to block the gun with "extramarital affairs", and the matter will naturally not develop to such an ugly point... She almost attributed all the resentment in her heart to Bai Duanduan.
It's all the lawyer's fault!
"I treat you as a friend, but you are using me with ulterior motives!"
But in the face of Tang Li's overwhelming anger, Bai Duanduan remained calm: "Tang Li, do you think you and I are friends? Do you think we are friends? Do you really regard me as a friend?"
Bai Duandan smiled: "But, Tang Li, if we were friends, how much do you know about me? Do you know my hobbies? Do you know my birthday? Do you know my taboos? You know my educational background, family background and other information?"
"You don't know, and you don't care to know, because your 'friend' standard is just to buy and buy bags with you, discuss luxury goods together, spend vanity together and show off with nothing to do, you don't care about yours at all" What kind of character is a friend, what kind of person, you only care about these superficial appearances, and your so-called internet celebrity friends, are they really your friends? They can take selfies and group photos with you Is there anything else besides beauty and business bragging? You don't know what you say about each other behind your back?"
"Tang Li, please remember that you and I have never been friends." Bai Duanduan looked at Tang Li almost pityingly, "This is not how friends get along, and I, Bai Duanduan, have never been friends. deceive friends."
You're not even close enough to be my friend.
This very cruel and straightforward sentence, Bai Duanduan could have said it, but she looked at the pale Tang Li, and finally did not say it.
"If you really make good friends and sincerely know a person's character to select friends, instead of casually looking at money and background to make friends with others, even if I change a hundred identities, I will have no chance to successfully obtain evidence from you in a short time .”
In fact, there are a lot of things that can be understood by a smart person, but Tang Li obviously can't accept the fact that he is also at fault.
"You're a lawyer, I can't say no to you, but didn't you blame me for getting me to this point?" Tang Li burst into tears, "I mistrusted my friend and my husband, and something happened in the end. You took it out to block the gun, but this case has nothing to do with me at all! It’s not that I broke the contract with my old company behind my back and went to work for other companies secretly, but in the end you all blamed it one by one Me! Obviously I am the most innocent person!"
When a dispute reached this point, Lu Shuisheng also knew that the situation was over, his face was ugly and depressed, as if he had no eyes to watch this bloody drama, and he didn't care about the arbitrator, he just walked away with a gloomy face, leaving the Mercury Network Legal affairs and lawyers continue to close.
Lin Hui was in a bad state from the beginning, and now he looked at Bai Duanduan without saying a word, his eyes were a little empty, and his expression was a little erratic. He was obviously in this arbitration tribunal, but he seemed to be thinking about something else.
Tang Li was still cursing and crying, but Tian Mu had calmed down after the initial anger. He looked at Tang Li, listened to Tang Li's accusation, and his face showed the sadness and sorrow that he was trying to suppress.
"Tang Li, do you think that all this is my fault?"
Tian Mu's voice trembled slightly: "Do you think that I violated the contract myself and caused these things to implicate you? Do you think everything has nothing to do with you?"
Tang Li just cried and didn't speak.
"You don't even know that the origin of all this is for you." Tian Mu's expression was heavy, he closed his eyes slightly, and then opened them with a tired expression, "I... I really love you, so I want to be satisfied All your requests, what you want to buy, I want you to be able to buy it, I don’t want you to feel wronged, I don’t want you to be unhappy, at the beginning, you just bought luxury brand bags, I was talking to Wen The salary of the game is completely affordable, but later you started to buy first-tier big names. At that time, my salary was already a bit difficult to maintain your consumption. I cashed out several credit cards, but they were not enough. I have no choice but to Trying to get some money from the company, sometimes falsely reporting some invoices, and even getting kickbacks."
Tian Mu lowered his head: "Originally, I could continue to work in Yuwen Game, but Mr. Xie became alienated from me because of my unclean hands and feet. In the end, the labor contract expired and he didn't renew the contract with me. I am also sorry for this." Not blaming others is my own problem. I was just thinking about you who kept arguing that I didn’t have time to accompany you. Since I left the job, it’s good to go home and accompany you. If it’s money, non-compete compensation It's enough to get by. In short, we just have to live well."
"But I didn't expect you to spend more and more ruthlessly. A bag of tens of thousands of yuan can no longer satisfy you. You start to buy Hermes worth hundreds of thousands of yuan. When you go out to spend and eat a meal, the average person can even exceed ten thousand. My competition The industry limit compensation is not enough for you to spend, and every time you don’t buy anything, you will be very unhappy and keep a straight face.” Tian Mu lowered his head, “I don’t want to see you unhappy, at this time Mercury Network just contacted me , I decided to do it.”
Tang Li looked at Tian Mu with tears in his eyes, and seemed to want to refute, but she really couldn't say anything.
"I'm not saying that it's your responsibility for things to turn out like this, but it's true that it's not your fault that the trouble has come to this point. I just think I'm ridiculous, and I'm betting my career with all my strength, and I want to give you what you want. Everything turned out to be a joke in the end, I broke the contract to help Lu Shuisheng with work, but you were half-hearted behind the scenes and flirted with Lu Shuisheng by accident..."
Tian Mu heaved a long sigh, and now, he has become the calmest person, and the bamboo basket was empty, he gave Tang Li a heavy and sad look: "Tang Li, I know you don't think I'm very good-looking In the same way, I didn’t make enough money. In the past few years, I may feel that I am not worthy of you. I rarely hold my hand when I go out. I never post my photos on Weibo, but I always feel that it’s okay. As long as I love you, we will have a long, long life together in the future."
Tang Li looked at Tian Mu, his pale face finally showed a different expression, she began to panic and panic.
Tian Mu looked at the arbitrator: "I admit that I violated the non-competition obligation, and I also accept the corresponding legal consequences, but this matter really has nothing to do with Tang Li, so I will bear the responsibility myself."
After he finished speaking, he looked at Tang Li: "I love you very much, but now I feel that I can't love you anymore." Tian Mu lowered his eyes, "Tang Li, let's get a divorce."
Tang Li was still complaining about Tian Mu's fault, but when she heard the word divorce, she rejected it quite violently: "No! I don't agree to divorce you!"
It's a pity that Tian Mu seems to have made up his mind. For things like love, once the heart is dead, it will be difficult to recover.
He calmly said: "After two years of separation, the divorce will be judged as a breakdown of feelings. I can give you the house, and I will move out."
Probably only when I lost it did I know how to cherish it. Relying on Tian Mu's love, Tang Li was used to lawlessness. He thought that even if he teased others, as long as he didn't actually cheat, and he apologized and acted coquettishly, there would always be room for maneuver. What's more, she still thought that this matter was Tian Mu's fault, and Tian Mu should apologize and admit his mistake, but she didn't expect things to turn out like this...
Originally, I always thought that Tian Mu was not good at anything, but when he said that he wanted a divorce, Tang Li panicked. Tian Mu is not handsome, but he is obedient to himself; he is not rich enough, but every penny is worthy I am willing to give myself flowers; I am not perfect, but I have a good temper and almost never get angry with myself, and I can tolerate everything about myself...
Once she really wanted to divorce, she remembered Tian Mu's good luck...
If I get divorced, can I find someone who treats me better than Tian Mu? There are indeed many rich and powerful people, but after divorce, I have become a second marriage. Will people want me? Even if he wanted it, since his status was so much higher than his own, wouldn't he have to be a little bit low every day and live carefully? Tang Li thought of his friend who married a wealthy businessman twenty years older than her. Although the money was enough, he basically had no freedom and no ego. will say two...
Sometimes people really have to lose to know how to cherish. Now Tian Mu's face is full of indifference after death, which finally makes Tang Li start to be afraid.
"Husband! Husband, I'm sorry! I didn't really blame you just now, it was my fault! I was not satisfied, I will change it in the future, if you think I spend too much money, then I spend less, and I can go out and make money myself , my Weibo account can accept advertisements... "
Tang Li was almost completely flustered, trying to pull back Tian Mu's intentions in an unreasonable way: "I... I have no intention of being with others, I know you are good to me, I didn't do well before, what do you give me?" I have a chance, I will change it in the future, I will never add strange men again, I can check my mobile phone for you at any time in the future, let's not divorce... "
It's a pity that feelings are often overwhelmed and hard to get back. Obviously, Tian Mu's long-term expectation and disappointment finally turned into despair. This man who used to ask for anything from Tang Li now looks at Tang Li who is crying. There is no special expression.
There are beauty and ugliness in marriage, and most of the time it is a kind of mutual compromise, but once the ugly things are fully exposed and honest, no amount of beauty can be whitewashed to make this marriage go on.
At the beginning of the arbitration hearing today, Tian Mu's face was relaxed and determined, but now, his face is only numb and tired, as if he is completely tired and tired, and he no longer wants to save his life and make any efforts , as if life could do whatever it wanted to him.
Ji Lin, Bai Duanduan and Xie Miao were both very surprised when he admitted that he had violated the non-compete agreement without even needing Ji Lin and Bai Duanduan to continue to provide evidence.
Although today's arbitral tribunal trial was interrupted by this farce, Bai Duanduan decisively turned on the recorder in the middle, coupled with the witness of the arbitrator and now Tian Mu's confession, and then reopened the court session, Xie Miao won the case, It's already an indisputable ending.
The author has something to say: Today's update is also very fat!
[small theater]
Ji Lin: Look at an old man like Lin Hui, who just hasn't slept all night, his complexion is so bad, and his dark circles are so heavy, isn't he suffering from kidney deficiency
Bai Duanduan: ...
Ji Lin: Look at me again, I also stayed up late for two days, look at my skin, is it as dull as his
Bai Duanduan: ...