It is not unusual for an academic to have his manuscript rejected.
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
"The retraction notice politely mentioned that I should modify the experimental data that seemed to be a bit 'exaggerated'. However, they did not say where the exaggeration was. I am even sure that they did not repeat the experiment because they did not have the conditions."
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
But looking at it now, his idea may still be a bit too idealistic.
When the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in an arms race, it wouldn't have turned into this...
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
Lu Zhou laughed and said, "What does this have to do with being a top student?"
Regardless of your reputation or past achievements, if the journal is not selected correctly, or the results do not meet the standards for publication, it is possible that the manuscript will be rejected at a certain stage of the review process.
Seeing the expression on Lu Zhou's face, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
"I think what he said makes sense."
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
He is not sure how much influence this International Conference on Integrated Circuit Design and Technology has in the industry. What makes him sigh is not because of the ridiculous reason, but that over the years, he has increasingly felt that academic purity Being with justice is becoming more and more like a piece of paper to wipe your ass.
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
After all, in his opinion, where the paper is submitted is secondary, the important thing is the paper itself. A sufficiently outstanding research result will definitely attract people's attention even if it is posted on Arxiv.
"I think what he said makes sense."
Let’s not discuss the broken journals and the manuscripts that are still in the queue. For papers that have been printed and published, every retraction is a big blow to the credibility of the journal, because it is equivalent to Publicly admit that the published paper contains significant and irreparable errors.
"'Future' is ready."
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
After all, in his opinion, where the paper is submitted is secondary, the important thing is the paper itself. A sufficiently outstanding research result will definitely attract people's attention even if it is posted on Arxiv.
However, this is the first time he has submitted an article to an IEEE journal. This kind of journal is biased towards the fields of engineering electrical and electronic engineering, and his professional field is still a bit far behind. Although a top journal in the field of electrical engineering had previously sent an invitation email, hoping that he could publish a paper on controllable fusion technology, considering that this technology involves a lot of things, he ultimately declined politely.
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
"Just call..."
But looking at it now, his idea may still be a bit too idealistic.
Therefore, generally speaking, journals are very cautious about retracting published papers unless extremely serious academic fraud or other things that damage the reputation of scholars have occurred.
Let’s not discuss the broken journals and the manuscripts that are still in the queue. For papers that have been printed and published, every retraction is a big blow to the credibility of the journal, because it is equivalent to Publicly admit that the published paper contains significant and irreparable errors.
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
"Change?" Hearing this question, Lu Zhou smiled lightly and said nonchalantly, "Why should we change something that is right?"
Although things in the field of biology cannot be compared side by side with the field of integrated circuit design, it is indeed quite unusual for the IEEE to suddenly withdraw papers even during the report meeting.
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
It is not unusual for an academic to have his manuscript rejected.
The incident of Haruko Obokata, a Nobel Prize-level academic fraud that caused a sensation in the biology community at that time, even though the entire academic community had already concluded that her experimental results were based on P-pictures, in the end it was RIKEN who could not withstand the pressure and stepped forward. Only after Fang himself obtained written consent to withdraw the STAP cell paper did Nature withdraw the controversial manuscript.
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
After spending about five minutes thinking about this question seriously, Lu Zhou raised his head and said.
After spending about five minutes thinking about this question seriously, Lu Zhou raised his head and said.
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
Although things in the field of biology cannot be compared side by side with the field of integrated circuit design, it is indeed quite unusual for the IEEE to suddenly withdraw papers even during the report meeting.
Lu Zhou laughed and said, "What does this have to do with being a top student?"
Lu Zhou nodded and said, "Before leaving yesterday, Warwick's boss discussed this issue with me."
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
"As expected of a top student, these words are very typical of you."
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
"'Future' is ready."
Chen Yushan: "Did they ask you to revise the paper or something like that?"
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
However, this is the first time he has submitted an article to an IEEE journal. This kind of journal is biased towards the fields of engineering electrical and electronic engineering, and his professional field is still a bit far behind. Although a top journal in the field of electrical engineering had previously sent an invitation email, hoping that he could publish a paper on controllable fusion technology, considering that this technology involves a lot of things, he ultimately declined politely.
Although things in the field of biology cannot be compared side by side with the field of integrated circuit design, it is indeed quite unusual for the IEEE to suddenly withdraw papers even during the report meeting.
"I think what he said makes sense."
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
Unexpectedly, the first time my name appeared at the top conference of IEEE, I would be kicked back, and the ridiculous reasons were "academic fraud" and "falsified experimental data."
The incident of Haruko Obokata, a Nobel Prize-level academic fraud that caused a sensation in the biology community at that time, even though the entire academic community had already concluded that her experimental results were based on P-pictures, in the end it was RIKEN who could not withstand the pressure and stepped forward. Only after Fang himself obtained written consent to withdraw the STAP cell paper did Nature withdraw the controversial manuscript.
"Change?" Hearing this question, Lu Zhou smiled lightly and said nonchalantly, "Why should we change something that is right?"
"As expected of a top student, these words are very typical of you."
But looking at it now, his idea may still be a bit too idealistic.
Although things in the field of biology cannot be compared side by side with the field of integrated circuit design, it is indeed quite unusual for the IEEE to suddenly withdraw papers even during the report meeting.
Chen Yushan: "Did they ask you to revise the paper or something like that?"
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
After seeing the written retraction notice sent by IEEE, Lu Zhou couldn't help but sigh.
Lu Zhou nodded and said, "Before leaving yesterday, Warwick's boss discussed this issue with me."
Conscience, is he the kind of person who would joke about experimental data
He is not sure how much influence this International Conference on Integrated Circuit Design and Technology has in the industry. What makes him sigh is not because of the ridiculous reason, but that over the years, he has increasingly felt that academic purity Being with justice is becoming more and more like a piece of paper to wipe your ass.
In fact, it was not just the boss of Warwick who told him about this issue, but his old friends in the domestic academic community also mentioned it to him during chats, but he didn't think it was troublesome and didn't take it too seriously. In the heart.
It is not unusual for an academic to have his manuscript rejected.
Seeing the expression on Lu Zhou's face, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
"It's just a metaphor, you have to argue with me." Rolling her eyes, Chen Yushan rolled her eyes. Suddenly an idea popped into her head, and she said on a whim, "Speaking of which, have you ever considered yourself?" Start a journal?”
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
Conscience, is he the kind of person who would joke about experimental data
"Where are all these things?" Lu Zhou sighed after hearing this strange metaphor, "And your comparison of IEEE to teachers is too exaggerated. They are not qualified enough."
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
"Where are all these things?" Lu Zhou sighed after hearing this strange metaphor, "And your comparison of IEEE to teachers is too exaggerated. They are not qualified enough."
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Conscience, is he the kind of person who would joke about experimental data
"It's just a metaphor, you have to argue with me." Rolling her eyes, Chen Yushan rolled her eyes. Suddenly an idea popped into her head, and she said on a whim, "Speaking of which, have you ever considered yourself?" Start a journal?”
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
He is not sure how much influence this International Conference on Integrated Circuit Design and Technology has in the industry. What makes him sigh is not because of the ridiculous reason, but that over the years, he has increasingly felt that academic purity Being with justice is becoming more and more like a piece of paper to wipe your ass.
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
However, this is the first time he has submitted an article to an IEEE journal. This kind of journal is biased towards the fields of engineering electrical and electronic engineering, and his professional field is still a bit far behind. Although a top journal in the field of electrical engineering had previously sent an invitation email, hoping that he could publish a paper on controllable fusion technology, considering that this technology involves a lot of things, he ultimately declined politely.
When the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in an arms race, it wouldn't have turned into this...
Unexpectedly, the first time my name appeared at the top conference of IEEE, I would be kicked back, and the ridiculous reasons were "academic fraud" and "falsified experimental data."
The incident of Haruko Obokata, a Nobel Prize-level academic fraud that caused a sensation in the biology community at that time, even though the entire academic community had already concluded that her experimental results were based on P-pictures, in the end it was RIKEN who could not withstand the pressure and stepped forward. Only after Fang himself obtained written consent to withdraw the STAP cell paper did Nature withdraw the controversial manuscript.
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
"It's just a metaphor, you have to argue with me." Rolling her eyes, Chen Yushan rolled her eyes. Suddenly an idea popped into her head, and she said on a whim, "Speaking of which, have you ever considered yourself?" Start a journal?”
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
"The retraction notice politely mentioned that I should modify the experimental data that seemed to be a bit 'exaggerated'. However, they did not say where the exaggeration was. I am even sure that they did not repeat the experiment because they did not have the conditions."
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
"'Future' is ready."
Sitting on the sofa in the office of the dean of the Institute for Advanced Study, when talking about this matter, Chen Yushan had a somewhat narrow smile on her face.
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
Lu Zhou nodded and said, "Before leaving yesterday, Warwick's boss discussed this issue with me."
Seeing the expression on Lu Zhou's face, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
"Change?" Hearing this question, Lu Zhou smiled lightly and said nonchalantly, "Why should we change something that is right?"
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
"Has Wang Zhengfei told you about this issue?" Chen Yushan glanced at Lu Zhou in surprise and asked curiously, "What did he say?"
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
Sitting on the sofa in the office of the dean of the Institute for Advanced Study, when talking about this matter, Chen Yushan had a somewhat narrow smile on her face.
"As expected of a top student, these words are very typical of you."
"What are you talking about? How can I rejoice in someone else's misfortune? It's just rare to see you deflated, so I'm a little surprised."
Unexpectedly, the first time my name appeared at the top conference of IEEE, I would be kicked back, and the ridiculous reasons were "academic fraud" and "falsified experimental data."
In fact, it was not just the boss of Warwick who told him about this issue, but his old friends in the domestic academic community also mentioned it to him during chats, but he didn't think it was troublesome and didn't take it too seriously. In the heart.
"I think what he said makes sense."
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
"I think what he said makes sense."
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
"It's just a metaphor, you have to argue with me." Rolling her eyes, Chen Yushan rolled her eyes. Suddenly an idea popped into her head, and she said on a whim, "Speaking of which, have you ever considered yourself?" Start a journal?”
Sitting on the sofa in the office of the dean of the Institute for Advanced Study, when talking about this matter, Chen Yushan had a somewhat narrow smile on her face.
Although it is true that journals are just a platform for publishing academic results, there are still some restrictions when speaking through someone else's microphone. Even if these constraints cannot be reflected under normal circumstances, and ordinary people cannot do such disgusting and tasteless things as unplugging the microphone and driving the speaker off the stage, it is obvious that IEEE has broken through this bottom line.
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
However, this is the first time he has submitted an article to an IEEE journal. This kind of journal is biased towards the fields of engineering electrical and electronic engineering, and his professional field is still a bit far behind. Although a top journal in the field of electrical engineering had previously sent an invitation email, hoping that he could publish a paper on controllable fusion technology, considering that this technology involves a lot of things, he ultimately declined politely.
Chen Yushan: "Did they ask you to revise the paper or something like that?"
"The retraction notice politely mentioned that I should modify the experimental data that seemed to be a bit 'exaggerated'. However, they did not say where the exaggeration was. I am even sure that they did not repeat the experiment because they did not have the conditions."
"By the way, let me ask, what do you plan to call this journal?"
"By the way, let me ask, what do you plan to call this journal?"
Although it is true that journals are just a platform for publishing academic results, there are still some restrictions when speaking through someone else's microphone. Even if these constraints cannot be reflected under normal circumstances, and ordinary people cannot do such disgusting and tasteless things as unplugging the microphone and driving the speaker off the stage, it is obvious that IEEE has broken through this bottom line.
But looking at it now, his idea may still be a bit too idealistic.
"As expected of a top student, these words are very typical of you."
Therefore, generally speaking, journals are very cautious about retracting published papers unless extremely serious academic fraud or other things that damage the reputation of scholars have occurred.
"The retraction notice politely mentioned that I should modify the experimental data that seemed to be a bit 'exaggerated'. However, they did not say where the exaggeration was. I am even sure that they did not repeat the experiment because they did not have the conditions."
"Just call..."
Chen Yushan: "Did they ask you to revise the paper or something like that?"
"The retraction notice politely mentioned that I should modify the experimental data that seemed to be a bit 'exaggerated'. However, they did not say where the exaggeration was. I am even sure that they did not repeat the experiment because they did not have the conditions."
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
Lu Zhou laughed and said, "What does this have to do with being a top student?"
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Lu Zhou thought for a while and repeated: "He said that carbon-based chips are something we have developed after all, and it would be inappropriate to leave it to others to review the manuscript. It is not that there is no research in the direction of carbon-based integrated circuits in the world. So, most research institutions and scholars’ understanding of this thing is still at the theoretical level. Asking their opinions is a bit too overwhelming.”
"I think what he said makes sense."
Although it is true that journals are just a platform for publishing academic results, there are still some restrictions when speaking through someone else's microphone. Even if these constraints cannot be reflected under normal circumstances, and ordinary people cannot do such disgusting and tasteless things as unplugging the microphone and driving the speaker off the stage, it is obvious that IEEE has broken through this bottom line.
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
"Change?" Hearing this question, Lu Zhou smiled lightly and said nonchalantly, "Why should we change something that is right?"
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
Unexpectedly, the first time my name appeared at the top conference of IEEE, I would be kicked back, and the ridiculous reasons were "academic fraud" and "falsified experimental data."
It's another matter to cooperate with the reviewers' opinions to correct obvious or easily misunderstood errors. To be honest, he didn't pay attention to such ambiguous or even false accusations.
The incident of Haruko Obokata, a Nobel Prize-level academic fraud that caused a sensation in the biology community at that time, even though the entire academic community had already concluded that her experimental results were based on P-pictures, in the end it was RIKEN who could not withstand the pressure and stepped forward. Only after Fang himself obtained written consent to withdraw the STAP cell paper did Nature withdraw the controversial manuscript.
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
Hearing Lu Zhou's request, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
Seeing the expression on Lu Zhou's face, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
"Where are all these things?" Lu Zhou sighed after hearing this strange metaphor, "And your comparison of IEEE to teachers is too exaggerated. They are not qualified enough."
"As expected of a top student, these words are very typical of you."
Therefore, generally speaking, journals are very cautious about retracting published papers unless extremely serious academic fraud or other things that damage the reputation of scholars have occurred.
"Where are all these things?" Lu Zhou sighed after hearing this strange metaphor, "And your comparison of IEEE to teachers is too exaggerated. They are not qualified enough."
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
However, this is the first time he has submitted an article to an IEEE journal. This kind of journal is biased towards the fields of engineering electrical and electronic engineering, and his professional field is still a bit far behind. Although a top journal in the field of electrical engineering had previously sent an invitation email, hoping that he could publish a paper on controllable fusion technology, considering that this technology involves a lot of things, he ultimately declined politely.
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
Lu Zhou laughed and said, "What does this have to do with being a top student?"
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
It's another matter to cooperate with the reviewers' opinions to correct obvious or easily misunderstood errors. To be honest, he didn't pay attention to such ambiguous or even false accusations.
"It's just a metaphor, you have to argue with me." Rolling her eyes, Chen Yushan rolled her eyes. Suddenly an idea popped into her head, and she said on a whim, "Speaking of which, have you ever considered yourself?" Start a journal?”
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
Chen Yushan: "Did they ask you to revise the paper or something like that?"
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
"Change?" Hearing this question, Lu Zhou smiled lightly and said nonchalantly, "Why should we change something that is right?"
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
The incident of Haruko Obokata, a Nobel Prize-level academic fraud that caused a sensation in the biology community at that time, even though the entire academic community had already concluded that her experimental results were based on P-pictures, in the end it was RIKEN who could not withstand the pressure and stepped forward. Only after Fang himself obtained written consent to withdraw the STAP cell paper did Nature withdraw the controversial manuscript.
"Where are all these things?" Lu Zhou sighed after hearing this strange metaphor, "And your comparison of IEEE to teachers is too exaggerated. They are not qualified enough."
Lu Zhou thought for a while and repeated: "He said that carbon-based chips are something we have developed after all, and it would be inappropriate to leave it to others to review the manuscript. It is not that there is no research in the direction of carbon-based integrated circuits in the world. So, most research institutions and scholars’ understanding of this thing is still at the theoretical level. Asking their opinions is a bit too overwhelming.”
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
After pausing for a moment, Lu Zhou smiled faintly and continued, "I looked back and thought about it carefully. Our Jinling Institute for Advanced Study has been established for so long and we don't even have a journal. It seems really shameless to say so. That’s right.”
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
"As expected of a top student, these words are very typical of you."
"Has Wang Zhengfei told you about this issue?" Chen Yushan glanced at Lu Zhou in surprise and asked curiously, "What did he say?"
He is not sure how much influence this International Conference on Integrated Circuit Design and Technology has in the industry. What makes him sigh is not because of the ridiculous reason, but that over the years, he has increasingly felt that academic purity Being with justice is becoming more and more like a piece of paper to wipe your ass.
"By the way, let me ask, what do you plan to call this journal?"
"It's just a metaphor, you have to argue with me." Rolling her eyes, Chen Yushan rolled her eyes. Suddenly an idea popped into her head, and she said on a whim, "Speaking of which, have you ever considered yourself?" Start a journal?”
Regardless of your reputation or past achievements, if the journal is not selected correctly, or the results do not meet the standards for publication, it is possible that the manuscript will be rejected at a certain stage of the review process.
Although it is true that journals are just a platform for publishing academic results, there are still some restrictions when speaking through someone else's microphone. Even if these constraints cannot be reflected under normal circumstances, and ordinary people cannot do such disgusting and tasteless things as unplugging the microphone and driving the speaker off the stage, it is obvious that IEEE has broken through this bottom line.
Lu Zhou thought for a while and repeated: "He said that carbon-based chips are something we have developed after all, and it would be inappropriate to leave it to others to review the manuscript. It is not that there is no research in the direction of carbon-based integrated circuits in the world. So, most research institutions and scholars’ understanding of this thing is still at the theoretical level. Asking their opinions is a bit too overwhelming.”
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
Hearing Lu Zhou's request, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
After pausing for a moment, Lu Zhou smiled faintly and continued, "I looked back and thought about it carefully. Our Jinling Institute for Advanced Study has been established for so long and we don't even have a journal. It seems really shameless to say so. That’s right.”
It is not unusual for an academic to have his manuscript rejected.
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Lu Zhou nodded and said, "Before leaving yesterday, Warwick's boss discussed this issue with me."
"Has Wang Zhengfei told you about this issue?" Chen Yushan glanced at Lu Zhou in surprise and asked curiously, "What did he say?"
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
When the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in an arms race, it wouldn't have turned into this...
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
It's another matter to cooperate with the reviewers' opinions to correct obvious or easily misunderstood errors. To be honest, he didn't pay attention to such ambiguous or even false accusations.
Lu Zhou nodded and said, "Before leaving yesterday, Warwick's boss discussed this issue with me."
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
In fact, it was not just the boss of Warwick who told him about this issue, but his old friends in the domestic academic community also mentioned it to him during chats, but he didn't think it was troublesome and didn't take it too seriously. In the heart.
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
Lu Zhou thought for a while and repeated: "He said that carbon-based chips are something we have developed after all, and it would be inappropriate to leave it to others to review the manuscript. It is not that there is no research in the direction of carbon-based integrated circuits in the world. So, most research institutions and scholars’ understanding of this thing is still at the theoretical level. Asking their opinions is a bit too overwhelming.”
"Why doesn't it matter? Think about it, when I was studying in the past, weren't the people who dared to talk back to the teacher about the standard answers all the top students? If he was a scumbag, the teacher would tell him he was wrong, and he would just give in. ”
The incident of Haruko Obokata, a Nobel Prize-level academic fraud that caused a sensation in the biology community at that time, even though the entire academic community had already concluded that her experimental results were based on P-pictures, in the end it was RIKEN who could not withstand the pressure and stepped forward. Only after Fang himself obtained written consent to withdraw the STAP cell paper did Nature withdraw the controversial manuscript.
After all, in his opinion, where the paper is submitted is secondary, the important thing is the paper itself. A sufficiently outstanding research result will definitely attract people's attention even if it is posted on Arxiv.
It is not unusual for an academic to have his manuscript rejected.
Lu Zhou nodded and said, "Before leaving yesterday, Warwick's boss discussed this issue with me."
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
"I think what he said makes sense."
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Sitting on the sofa in the office of the dean of the Institute for Advanced Study, when talking about this matter, Chen Yushan had a somewhat narrow smile on her face.
"Has Wang Zhengfei told you about this issue?" Chen Yushan glanced at Lu Zhou in surprise and asked curiously, "What did he say?"
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
"The retraction notice politely mentioned that I should modify the experimental data that seemed to be a bit 'exaggerated'. However, they did not say where the exaggeration was. I am even sure that they did not repeat the experiment because they did not have the conditions."
After pausing for a moment, Lu Zhou smiled faintly and continued, "I looked back and thought about it carefully. Our Jinling Institute for Advanced Study has been established for so long and we don't even have a journal. It seems really shameless to say so. That’s right.”
"Where are all these things?" Lu Zhou sighed after hearing this strange metaphor, "And your comparison of IEEE to teachers is too exaggerated. They are not qualified enough."
"By the way, let me ask, what do you plan to call this journal?"
But looking at it now, his idea may still be a bit too idealistic.
Regardless of your reputation or past achievements, if the journal is not selected correctly, or the results do not meet the standards for publication, it is possible that the manuscript will be rejected at a certain stage of the review process.
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
Although it is true that journals are just a platform for publishing academic results, there are still some restrictions when speaking through someone else's microphone. Even if these constraints cannot be reflected under normal circumstances, and ordinary people cannot do such disgusting and tasteless things as unplugging the microphone and driving the speaker off the stage, it is obvious that IEEE has broken through this bottom line.
After all, in his opinion, where the paper is submitted is secondary, the important thing is the paper itself. A sufficiently outstanding research result will definitely attract people's attention even if it is posted on Arxiv.
Let’s not discuss the broken journals and the manuscripts that are still in the queue. For papers that have been printed and published, every retraction is a big blow to the credibility of the journal, because it is equivalent to Publicly admit that the published paper contains significant and irreparable errors.
Sitting on the sofa in the office of the dean of the Institute for Advanced Study, when talking about this matter, Chen Yushan had a somewhat narrow smile on her face.
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
Although things in the field of biology cannot be compared side by side with the field of integrated circuit design, it is indeed quite unusual for the IEEE to suddenly withdraw papers even during the report meeting.
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
Perhaps, I should really consider starting an academic journal and do it myself.
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
Although it is true that journals are just a platform for publishing academic results, there are still some restrictions when speaking through someone else's microphone. Even if these constraints cannot be reflected under normal circumstances, and ordinary people cannot do such disgusting and tasteless things as unplugging the microphone and driving the speaker off the stage, it is obvious that IEEE has broken through this bottom line.
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
When the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in an arms race, it wouldn't have turned into this...
"Has Wang Zhengfei told you about this issue?" Chen Yushan glanced at Lu Zhou in surprise and asked curiously, "What did he say?"
When the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in an arms race, it wouldn't have turned into this...
"Has Wang Zhengfei told you about this issue?" Chen Yushan glanced at Lu Zhou in surprise and asked curiously, "What did he say?"
Lu Zhou thought for a while and repeated: "He said that carbon-based chips are something we have developed after all, and it would be inappropriate to leave it to others to review the manuscript. It is not that there is no research in the direction of carbon-based integrated circuits in the world. So, most research institutions and scholars’ understanding of this thing is still at the theoretical level. Asking their opinions is a bit too overwhelming.”
After spending about five minutes thinking about this question seriously, Lu Zhou raised his head and said.
"Where are all these things?" Lu Zhou sighed after hearing this strange metaphor, "And your comparison of IEEE to teachers is too exaggerated. They are not qualified enough."
He is not sure how much influence this International Conference on Integrated Circuit Design and Technology has in the industry. What makes him sigh is not because of the ridiculous reason, but that over the years, he has increasingly felt that academic purity Being with justice is becoming more and more like a piece of paper to wipe your ass.
Hearing Lu Zhou's request, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
"Just call..."
Regardless of your reputation or past achievements, if the journal is not selected correctly, or the results do not meet the standards for publication, it is possible that the manuscript will be rejected at a certain stage of the review process.
Nodding thoughtfully, Chen Yushan said, "I think so too... What do you mean?"
After pausing for a moment, Lu Zhou smiled faintly and continued, "I looked back and thought about it carefully. Our Jinling Institute for Advanced Study has been established for so long and we don't even have a journal. It seems really shameless to say so. That’s right.”
Nodding thoughtfully, Chen Yushan said, "I think so too... What do you mean?"
Therefore, generally speaking, journals are very cautious about retracting published papers unless extremely serious academic fraud or other things that damage the reputation of scholars have occurred.
However, this is the first time he has submitted an article to an IEEE journal. This kind of journal is biased towards the fields of engineering electrical and electronic engineering, and his professional field is still a bit far behind. Although a top journal in the field of electrical engineering had previously sent an invitation email, hoping that he could publish a paper on controllable fusion technology, considering that this technology involves a lot of things, he ultimately declined politely.
Conscience, is he the kind of person who would joke about experimental data
"I think what he said makes sense."
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Unexpectedly, the first time my name appeared at the top conference of IEEE, I would be kicked back, and the ridiculous reasons were "academic fraud" and "falsified experimental data."
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
In fact, it was not just the boss of Warwick who told him about this issue, but his old friends in the domestic academic community also mentioned it to him during chats, but he didn't think it was troublesome and didn't take it too seriously. In the heart.
Regardless of your reputation or past achievements, if the journal is not selected correctly, or the results do not meet the standards for publication, it is possible that the manuscript will be rejected at a certain stage of the review process.
"The retraction notice politely mentioned that I should modify the experimental data that seemed to be a bit 'exaggerated'. However, they did not say where the exaggeration was. I am even sure that they did not repeat the experiment because they did not have the conditions."
After pausing for a moment, Lu Zhou smiled faintly and continued, "I looked back and thought about it carefully. Our Jinling Institute for Advanced Study has been established for so long and we don't even have a journal. It seems really shameless to say so. That’s right.”
"I think what he said makes sense."
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
Let’s not discuss the broken journals and the manuscripts that are still in the queue. For papers that have been printed and published, every retraction is a big blow to the credibility of the journal, because it is equivalent to Publicly admit that the published paper contains significant and irreparable errors.
"I plan to establish a comprehensive subject journal in the name of the Institute for Advanced Study... Of course, even people who are not from our Institute for Advanced Study can submit articles, but we must take the review aspect into our own hands."
Hearing Lu Zhou's request, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
Perhaps, I should really consider starting an academic journal and do it myself.
It is not unusual for an academic to have his manuscript rejected.
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
When the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in an arms race, it wouldn't have turned into this...
Let’s not discuss the broken journals and the manuscripts that are still in the queue. For papers that have been printed and published, every retraction is a big blow to the credibility of the journal, because it is equivalent to Publicly admit that the published paper contains significant and irreparable errors.
After pausing for a moment, Lu Zhou smiled faintly and continued, "I looked back and thought about it carefully. Our Jinling Institute for Advanced Study has been established for so long and we don't even have a journal. It seems really shameless to say so. That’s right.”
Lu Zhou joked to himself and said, "It's hard to talk about being defeated. It's just that I finally missed face at the IEEE and was kicked back again."
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
"That's for sure. I don't understand these things. I can be the editor-in-chief for the time being, but I still have to leave it to you to establish the journal."
Therefore, generally speaking, journals are very cautious about retracting published papers unless extremely serious academic fraud or other things that damage the reputation of scholars have occurred.
Chen Yushan: "Do you need my help?"
After seeing the written retraction notice sent by IEEE, Lu Zhou couldn't help but sigh.
Lu Zhou laughed and said, "What does this have to do with being a top student?"
Hearing Lu Zhou's request, Chen Yushan couldn't help but curl her lips.
Nodding thoughtfully, Chen Yushan said, "I think so too... What do you mean?"
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Although things in the field of biology cannot be compared side by side with the field of integrated circuit design, it is indeed quite unusual for the IEEE to suddenly withdraw papers even during the report meeting.
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Lu Zhou laughed and said, "What does this have to do with being a top student?"
But looking at it now, his idea may still be a bit too idealistic.
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
"It's a small matter, just leave it to me."
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
Speaking of this, she suddenly remembered something very important, so she asked.
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
Therefore, generally speaking, journals are very cautious about retracting published papers unless extremely serious academic fraud or other things that damage the reputation of scholars have occurred.
"By the way, let me ask, what do you plan to call this journal?"
After all, in his opinion, where the paper is submitted is secondary, the important thing is the paper itself. A sufficiently outstanding research result will definitely attract people's attention even if it is posted on Arxiv.
After seeing the written retraction notice sent by IEEE, Lu Zhou couldn't help but sigh.
"I think what he said makes sense."
"I heard that your manuscript was withdrawn?"
After spending about five minutes thinking about this question seriously, Lu Zhou raised his head and said.
Although things in the field of biology cannot be compared side by side with the field of integrated circuit design, it is indeed quite unusual for the IEEE to suddenly withdraw papers even during the report meeting.
Only those research results that are not particularly important, or even dispensable, need to reflect their value through the authority of the journal itself.
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
"What are you talking about? How can I rejoice in someone else's misfortune? It's just rare to see you deflated, so I'm a little surprised."
However, not everyone has the opportunity to encounter a published paper that has been withdrawn.
It's another matter to cooperate with the reviewers' opinions to correct obvious or easily misunderstood errors. To be honest, he didn't pay attention to such ambiguous or even false accusations.
"Just call..."
Chen Yushan: "Did they ask you to revise the paper or something like that?"
Seeing her gloating look, Lu Zhou sighed, made a helpless expression and said, "My manuscript was retracted, am I so happy?"
Chen Yushan asked curiously: "Then do you plan to change it?"
It is not unusual for an academic to have his manuscript rejected.
"As expected of a top student, these words are very typical of you."
"It's just a metaphor, you have to argue with me." Rolling her eyes, Chen Yushan rolled her eyes. Suddenly an idea popped into her head, and she said on a whim, "Speaking of which, have you ever considered yourself?" Start a journal?”
"Has Wang Zhengfei told you about this issue?" Chen Yushan glanced at Lu Zhou in surprise and asked curiously, "What did he say?"
"'Future' is ready."
Nodding thoughtfully, Chen Yushan said, "I think so too... What do you mean?"
In short, after being rejected for the first time in his life, this time even the retraction of the manuscript was arranged. Lu Zhou felt that he probably had no regrets in his academic career.
"Just call..."