After this idea came up, netizens were confused...
No one can give a definite answer to the three questions raised by Long Yang.
For a while.
Everyone's curiosity was aroused and they looked down.
After Long Yang raised three questions, he indeed gave an explanation in the subsequent film review:
“Let’s talk about the first question first: why did the ferry have an accident
Many people overlooked the scene where the father fed the animals. Because animals can get seasick, the father hoped to use anesthetics to calm the animals down while sailing.
But the surprising thing is...
These things were done by servants in the past, and my father had never given anesthetics to animals, so his anesthetics accidentally got into the crew's food.
Because of the quarrel between the mother and the chef, the protagonist and his family did not eat during the day.
therefore.
When the storm came, the people on the boat did not wake up due to the effect of anesthetics, and no sailor took timely and effective measures, so the ferry was in trouble. This is the decisive reason why Pi always avoided the cause of the shipwreck.
A top filmmaker won't give you useless footage.
Those seemingly meaningless shots may be foreshadowing hidden in the dark. If you don’t think carefully, it’s easy to overlook key information. The protagonist’s family didn’t eat, and the anesthetics fed to the animals are what I call key information!
… ”
Netizens widened their eyes!
No one had thought of this problem beforehand!
Shipwreck…
Was it because of my father’s mistake
Some netizens subconsciously wanted to refute, how did the cook and the sailor get into the lifeboat
However.
The interpretation of the next two questions provided an explanation and also shut up netizens.
“Once the first question is answered, the answers to the second and third questions can directly overturn the second story told by the faction.
I believe someone has already guessed it.
In fact, there were no sailors or cooks at all!
All the crew members were wiped out, and the only ones who boarded the ship were the protagonist's family!
The so-called zebra is not a sailor at all, but the protagonist's father; the hyena is the protagonist's brother; and the mouse is the protagonist's girlfriend, who also sneaked on board. I believe many netizens have guessed this, as mouse itself is a word used to describe stowaways.
This is the answer to the third question.
Why did the mother hit the cook but the cook didn't fight back
Because the cook is a hyena, who is the protagonist's brother.
It is normal for my brother not to fight back when his mother hit him.
The elder brother used the father's amputated leg to fish, which of course the mother could not tolerate, but the elder brother was a rational person, and the foreshadowing in the first thirty minutes was not in vain. It was just that the father died because he could not get effective treatment for the amputation, so the elder brother ate his father's flesh in order to survive.
… ”
Netizens were completely stunned!
No cooks and sailors
The ones who boarded the ship were actually the protagonist's family
This interpretation is countless times more terrifying than the previous one, and it makes people feel cold all over!
"You probably have guessed what happened next. My mother and my brother had a conflict, and my mother was accidentally killed by my brother.
The protagonist was completely enraged and he killed his brother!
If the brother was really the cook, he would have fought back long ago, but he is actually the brother, so he did not fight back because he also knew that he had done something wrong.
So, the protagonist and his brother were left on the boat.
The protagonist said that he remembered every detail of his last day with his girlfriend but he couldn't remember how they parted. In fact, it's not that he couldn't remember, it's that they didn't part, and the way they parted was so cruel that Pi couldn't even try to make it up.
… ”
Having said this, Long Yang summarized:
"My guess may not be completely correct, but it is definitely closer to the truth than the second version. There are too many metaphors in the shots in this movie, such as the sulfuric acid that appears in the center of the lake on the Cannibal Island at night, which is actually human stomach acid, etc., but I can be sure that there are loopholes in the second version of Pi, which has been hinted at in the movie, especially the controversial point of whether the banana can carry the gorilla, which is the biggest clue, and the protagonist's family must be on the boat, which is why the story of the protagonist's family is constantly playing in the first thirty minutes of the movie to pave the way!
The same thing.
A good filmmaker will not use meaningless shots. The seemingly useless foreshadowing in the first thirty minutes is actually a foreshadowing that the cook and the sailor are also family. Only when you understand this will you truly understand the horror of this movie.
… ”
The movie review is over.
After reading the film reviews, netizens were stunned!
Cannibalism itself is already very horrifying, but no one expected that the real truth is countless times more horrifying than the second version of the story!
We are a family on board!
This is completely different from the second version of the story!
"I wanted to refute, but I couldn't find a foothold!"
"Oh my god, the protagonist eats his girlfriend and mother in the end?"
“Ahh, give me back the first version!”
"How beautiful the first version is, how dark the third version is!"
"It turns out that the tiger is the animal nature of the protagonist. The process of the taming of the tiger by the faction is the process of the human nature taming the animal nature!"
“This interpretation is absolutely amazing!”
"I was wondering why the first thirty minutes were so boring, talking about a lot of family matters, but after the ferry crashed, all the family members died, leaving only the mother and the protagonist on the boat. So this is why!"
"This is a story that was filmed so beautifully. My worldview collapsed!"
"This is the movie with the most metaphors I've ever seen. Where's the commercial film?"
"Xianyu's imagination is truly unmatched!"
“Oh my god!”
"… "
The interpretation reached its craziest climax!
Of course, there were people in the comments who refuted Long Yang, but they were just extensions of more interpretations, and the versions could not be unified at all. For example, some people believed that the hyena was the father and the zebra was the brother, because the father ate meat and the other family members were vegetarians.
even.
Some people mentioned the power of gods and religion and faith, which also makes sense.
Obviously.
The movie does not give a standard answer, and the creative team will not give it outside the movie. This is the most charming part of art films.
Just like in the story of Journey to the West, Sun Wukong is always interpreted from various perspectives...
Both the facts and the secondary creation are destined to be shrouded in mystery!
The only thing that is certain is that this story is much darker than anyone imagined!
After studying it over and over again, netizens are going crazy!
And the behavior of Young Pi has also caused countless controversies!
Some people think that the party is crazy.
Some people think that Pi went from being lost to being redeemed and gained liberation from humanity.
This seems to be back to the question at the end of the movie:
Do you prefer the version with tigers or the version without tigers
Very strange.
When the second version appeared, many people thought that it was more exciting without the tiger; but when the interpretation of the third version appeared, everyone suddenly began to want to choose the first version.
The movie itself is also about this.
Believe whichever you like.
So the question left by this movie becomes thought-provoking -
Which version do you like
—————
ps: The gaps of this movie have been almost filled, and I haven’t decided what to shoot for the next movie. I’m asking for your monthly vote and by the way, does anyone have any good suggestions