Gu Nianzhi narrowed his eyes, stood up and said calmly: "Objection. The defendant's lawyer's statement is misleading. My witness did not lie about the case. As for personal privacy, to be honest, the defendant's lawyer crossed the line. .”
She knew that Huo Guanchen was a scumbag in this matter, but this was a matter between a man and a woman, between Huo Guanchen, Bai Jinyi and Song Jinning. It had nothing to do with the case of Luo Jialan's deliberate murder of Song Jinning.
Cai Shengnan turned around neatly, looked at her with a pair of big and deep-set eyes, and said calmly: "Yes, Mr. Huo Guanchen's lies have little to do with his testimony, but he can lie in court, and he is proving his character. The fact that he lied is enough to show that his testimony is not credible."
Gu Nianzhi realized that Cai Shengnan used a matter between a man and a woman to induce Huo Guanchen to lie, in order to deprive him of his witness qualifications.
If a witness lies in court, if it is a lie related to the facts of the case, it is a crime of perjury.
If it is a lie that has nothing to do with the case, it will directly affect his qualifications as a witness.
What happened just now is not a big deal, because no matter what, it was just an affair between a man and a woman more than ten years ago.
But it is not trivial to say the least. It can prove that Huo Guanchen had an affair with Bai Jinyi before they were divorced. His morals are corrupt and his character is worrying.
This proves that what Huo Guanchen just testified is also not credible.
For example, how Luo Jialan treated Song Jinning in daily life, which ones were suspected of abuse, which ones were suspected of inducement, and which ones were for wanting her life. These things will be judged credible if they come from Huo Guanchen's mouth.
Moreover, Song Jinning was in court, and exposing this scandal in court was enough to make the relationship between Song Jinning and Huo Guanchen never go back.
So Bai Jinyi was willing to tell Cai Shengnan about this matter, probably with this purpose...
She couldn't get Huo Guanyuan, nor could she be with Huo Guanchen, but it was impossible for Song Jinning to be with Huo Guanyuan, let alone reunite with Huo Guanchen.
Gu Nianzhi understood Bai Jinyi and Cai Shengnan's sinister intentions in this matter, and became even more vigilant.
The opponent was not only stronger than she imagined, but also more shameless than she expected.
A lawyer who is both capable and has no bottom line is the most difficult lawyer to deal with.
Because they will do anything to win.
Gu Nianzhi pursed his lips and insisted again: "The love affair between Mr. Huo Guanchen and Bai Jinyi many years ago has nothing to do with this case. The defendant's lawyer should not ask about it at all. But you still insist on asking. My witness has no obligation to satisfy you. This kind of dark mentality that peeks into people’s privacy.”
"Is this privacy?" Cai Shengnan spread his hands in a funny manner, walked around in front of everyone in the court, then walked up to Song Jinning, looked at Song Jinning, whose face turned from red to white, and said regretfully: "Ms. Song Jinning, I I am very sympathetic to your experience, and I hate those who abused you, but my client..."
She turned back and pointed at Luo Jialan in the dock, "She really didn't want to murder you. She is such an extremely simple and extremely stupid person. As upright as she is, she once resented you, but after she hated you , seeing your experience, she felt more sympathy."
Luo Jialan also looked at them. When she heard Cai Shengnan speak, she immediately had tears in her eyes. She cupped her hands and arched her hands towards Song Jinning, making a pitiful gesture of begging for forgiveness.
Song Jinning had a frosty face and said coldly: "Sympathy? Don't think that you can fool me just because I was unconscious for more than ten years. My room in the Huo family is still sealed. When I lived there, it was Whatever it is, it is what it is now. Under her 'careful care', my physical condition has been deteriorating, which is proven by medical evaluation."
"Lawyer Cai, I'm a scientist. Tell me, do I believe the real data, or do I believe you just opened your mouth and told lies, insisting that she didn't want to murder me?"
Cai Shengnan was startled, and secretly thought that Song Jinning was really sharp, it was rare for him to have a clear mind, and it was difficult to be led...
Take a closer look at Song Jinning's face. Her skin is smooth and soft, with no fine lines at all. She looks like she is in her thirties at most, which is the peak period for a woman's skin to mature.
Although it is not as youthful and invincible as Gu Nianzhi's skin, but considering her age of forty-nine and soon to be fifty, it is really incredible.
Not only did she secretly wonder, how did Song Jinning recover from such severe brain trauma
This thought only flashed through her mind, and then she threw it aside.
Now it is not about how Song Jinning recovers.
The problem now is to continue their trial and eliminate Huo Guanchen, the most direct witness.
Because of Song Jinning's treatment in the Huo family, Huo Guanchen, besides Luo Jialan, knows the best.
He didn't interfere with how Luo Jialan treated Song Jinning, but he saw it all.
On Cai Shengnan and Luo Jialan's list, Huo Guanchen is the most difficult witness to deal with, not only because of his high position and what he says will greatly affect everyone, but also because he provides direct testimony.
Cai Shengnan saw that Song Jinning was not in a good position, so he refused to take the bait. He turned to face the judge and took out another piece of information contained in a water-red translucent folder.
"Your Honor, this is an academic article published in the world's most authoritative psychiatric journal, The American Journal of Psychiatry. It mentions a case that is very similar to Ms. Song Jinning's case, in which the brain suffered an explosion shock wave. The trauma caused short-term memory loss and mental disorder, thinking that his age was stuck in a certain era in the past."
"According to this magazine, there is no precedent for such a case to be cured in the world. Of course, Ms. Song Jinning's case is an exception among exceptions. She not only cured the mental illness, but also cured the damaged brain, which That’s really commendable.”
Gu Nianzhi stared at the folder in Cai Shengnan's hand with dark eyes, not knowing what he was thinking.
At this point, Cai Shengnan glanced back at the faces of everyone in the courtroom, and then turned to the judge and said: "This scientific document shows that this kind of brain injury causes both mental and physical diseases, and will itself worsen step by step. No matter how carefully you take care of it, or how good your psychiatrist is, you can't stop its final direction."
Oh, there are really two brushes.
Gu Nianzhi couldn't help but raise his eyebrows and sigh secretly.
If Cai Shengnan wins this argument, Luo Jialan may not be released in court, and she will never be charged with the same crime again unless new evidence is found.
But it took them almost a year to find the current evidence.
If Luo Jialan escapes this time, where will they find the second set of evidence
"... In other words, no matter how hard my client tries, Song Jinning's condition will still worsen. In this case, how can the prosecution lawyer prove that Ms. Song Jinning blames the deterioration of Ms. Song Jinning's physical condition on my client's intentional mental abuse? —We will not bear the blame."
Get rid of the witnesses first, and then get rid of the evidence. Naturally, Luo Jialan's intentional murder will not be established.
Cai Shengnan's operation can be said to be amazing.
If the two weren't on opposing sides, Gu Nianzhi would have called Cai Shengnan.
※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※
This is the second update today: Chapter 1358 "Straightforward, Simple and Stupid".
[The cute little Corgi continues to stand as a military dog and bow with its paws arched]: Dear beautiful ladies and handsome brothers, can you vote for my little master? If you don’t have a monthly pass, you won’t have dog food to eat QAQ~~~
The third update will be added to the monthly ticket at 9pm.
PS: First line: Upright, simple and stupid.
Second line:
Please follow the link.
mwah!
╰(*°▽°*)╯.