Cai Shengnan's statement can be considered well-founded and very persuasive.
Even the judge couldn't help but nodded and asked Gu Nianzhi pleasantly: "Prosecution lawyer, do you agree?"
Of course Gu Nianzhi couldn't agree.
Gu Nianzhi was thinking quickly, stood up slowly, and said, "The defendant's lawyer has presented a new piece of evidence. I would like to ask the defendant's lawyer whether the cases listed in this magazine are indeed my client's cases." , exactly the same?"
Gu Nianzhi's emphasis on "exactly the same" is to remind everyone not to be misled by something that is specious.
Cai Shengnan's heart skipped a beat and he said with a smile: "Of course they are exactly the same. I can show you the comparison chart made by experts..."
She then returned to the dock, opened her laptop and connected it to the large projector in the courtroom.
Soon, a comparison chart was displayed on the snow-white projection screen in the courtroom, comparing the cases in the literature with Song Jinning's case.
"Everyone, please take a look. The description of the case here is 80% similar to Song Jinning's description of the condition. It can be concluded..."
"Wait a minute." Gu Nianzhi raised his hand and called a pause. "I'll ask the defendant's lawyer again, who made this comparison chart? Expert? Which expert witness is it?"
Anything that can be brought to court must withstand scrutiny.
In addition to ordinary witnesses, expert witnesses are also very important.
Moreover, expert witnesses do not need to avoid the courtroom portion of cross-examination like ordinary witnesses. They can sit in the courtroom from beginning to end and observe the entire trial process.
But now in Court No. 1, there is only an ordinary witness, Huo Guanchen, and there are no expert witnesses.
Cai Shengnan said with a smile: "Of course he is an expert, but he is very busy and does not have time to appear in court, but he signed a certificate for me to prove that this evidence was provided by him."
Cai Shengnan circulated the expert's signature to the people in the court.
Gu Nianzhi also looked at the signature, then returned the certificate to Cai Shengnan, and continued to look up at the case comparison on the big screen and quickly read it.
When he saw the last comparison frame, Gu Nianzhi's eyes narrowed slightly.
"Defendant's lawyer, if the similarity of the disease descriptions is 80%, can it prove that it is the same disease?" Gu Nianzhi picked up the laser pointer in front of him and circled the last comparison box on the large projection screen, "Everyone, please Look, the last comparison between these two cases is the cure."
"Experts have clearly stated that this kind of case in the literature is incurable. That is to say, as the defendant's lawyer said, no matter how you take care of it, the final result will definitely worsen and the patient will definitely die."
"But after my client was released from the custody and care of the defendant Luo Jialan, not only did his condition not worsen, but he was also cured. Based on this alone, can you conclude that the two cases are the same disease?"
Gu Nianzhi found a loophole in Cai Shengnan's argument and began to pursue it. "Ebola virus is spread through blood and body fluids, and AIDS is also spread through blood and body fluids."
"The early symptoms of Ebola are fever, weakness, and body aches, similar to the flu."
"Coincidentally, the early symptoms of AIDS are also fever, weakness, and night sweats, which are similar to the flu."
"If we don't look at the later development, the similarity between the two may be 80%, so we can conclude that the two are exactly the same cases?"
"You think it's ridiculous too, don't you?"
Gu Nianzhi also glanced at the faces of everyone in the court and continued with a smile: "With this question, I would like to ask the expert witness invited by the defendant's lawyer how he came to the conclusion that the two causes of illness are 10%. Eighty percent similarity is the conclusion of the same disease."
Cai Shengnan quickly read his expert testimony and immediately retorted: "Please don't add drama to the prosecution's lawyer. My expert witness did not say that these two diseases are the same disease."
It was her words that Gu Nianzhi was waiting for. After hearing this, he immediately said: "Since it cannot be proven that these two diseases are the same disease, it means that the suspicion that the defendant Luo Jialan attempted to mentally abuse my client to death still exists."
"I would like to ask the defendant's lawyer, why do you use the case results in this magazine to prove that my client's disease will definitely worsen and he will definitely die? Are you trying to change the concept or committing perjury?!"
Whether it is a covert change of concept or perjury, it is a very serious accusation for the witness.
Cai Shengnan changed his face instantly and said in a deep voice: "Objection. My expert witness did not say such a thing."
"Your expert witness did not say anything like this. That is what you said, lawyer Cai, the defendant's lawyer. Then you are the one suspected of committing perjury."
Gu Nianzhi walked up to Cai Shengnan and stood in front of him. His big eyes were as dark as jade and he smiled slightly: "So, either you admit that your expert testimony is not applicable to this case, or you admit that you committed perjury. Choose one, Attorney Cai?" "
A look of embarrassment flashed in Cai Shengnan's eyes, but she quickly calmed down and said calmly: "This testimony is just circumstantial evidence. If the prosecution lawyer doesn't like it, then it shouldn't be used as evidence in this case."
The testimony she paid a lot of money to rush to get the psychiatrist to give was invalidated.
Cai Shengnan felt a little regretful, but at this time, cutting off a strong man's wrist was the clearest choice.
Gu Nianzhi nodded and said approvingly: "The defendant's lawyer is quick to see opportunities, knows his mistakes and can correct them, which is a great thing."
Cai Shengnan's face twitched twice, and he almost vomited blood when Gu Nianzhi choked him.
This road doesn't work, it doesn't matter, she has other ways.
Cai Shengnan quickly regained his composure and said to the judge: "Your Honor, I want to summon two of my witnesses. Please leave the prosecution's witnesses."
The judge agreed to her request, banged the gavel and asked Huo Guanchen to leave, and at the same time asked the bailiff to bring in Mrs. Xing, one of the two witnesses for the defendant.
Sister-in-law Xing was the housekeeping staff who came to the Huo family after Luo Jialan took over the care of Song Jinning.
She holds a professional certificate in caring for mentally ill patients and is highly sought after in the domestic service industry.
Arriving at the witness stand in Court No. 1, Mrs. Xing swore once again that she was telling the truth and would only tell the truth.
However, although the witness was swearing, no one truly believed that the witness would tell the truth because he swore.
People who like to lie swear that they are also lying, which is not a contradiction.
If you believe that what the witness says must be true, your IQ is not suitable for practicing law.
Gu Nianzhi returned to the plaintiff's table and sat down, her palms were wet. She had broken into a cold sweat just now and was almost frightened by Cai Shengnan.
Song Jinning's hand quietly reached out, took Gu Nianzhi's hand, and shook it hard.
This is meant to encourage her.
Gu Nianzhi relaxed, looked at Song Jinning, smiled, and mouthed, "I'm fine, thank you."
Song Jinning looked at Gu Nianzhi with pity, thinking that this little girl's face was pale and the sweat was dripping from her forehead, and she still said she was fine...
It's not easy to be a trial lawyer. If you don't work hard, you will be defeated by the other party every minute.
While fighting for wits, they are also fighting for physical strength.
Gu Nianzhi shook Song Jinning's hand and motioned her to look at the witness box.
In front of the witness box, Cai Shengnan had already walked over, stood in front of Sister-in-law Xing, and asked quietly: "Sister-in-law Xing, right? How long have you been taking care of Ms. Song Jinning in the Huo family?"
Sister-in-law Xing glanced at Song Jinning on the plaintiff's bench timidly, lowered her eyelids, "...six years."
She joined the Huo family one year after Luo Jialan took over Song Jinning.
The housekeeping staff who used to take care of Song Jinning were fired by Luo Jialan.
"Take care of her for six years? Tell me, why did you try to murder Ms. Song Jinning?" Cai Shengnan changed the topic and suddenly pointed out that Mrs. Xing was the murder suspect of Song Jinning!
Mrs. Xing suddenly raised her head and looked at Cai Shengnan in disbelief: "What what?! I attempted murder?! Wasn't I a witness?! Why did you say I attempted murder?!"
Not only Mrs. Xing was shocked, but everyone in the court was also shocked.
Gu Nianzhi's eyes wandered between Mrs. Xing and Cai Shengnan, frowning slightly, thinking, what is Cai Shengnan doing
The scapegoat was found on the witness
※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※※
This is the third update today: Chapter 1359 "Don't add drama to yourself".
[The cute little Corgi continues to stand with his paws arched and bowing as a military dog]: Dear beautiful ladies and handsome brothers, it’s been the last three hours, and my little master is waiting to be fed. How many monthly passes do you need!
Without a monthly pass, there is no dog food to eat. Sangxin qaq~~~
ps: If there are no more monthly votes, remember to vote for the next month’s monthly vote to the Major General after twelve o’clock~~~
mwah!
(*°°*).